I Was a Sword When I Reincarnated (WN)

Description

Links are NOT allowed. Format your description nicely so people can easily read them. Please use proper spacing and paragraphs.

When I noticed it, I was in a different world.

I had become a sword…what, I don’t get it! The place I woke up was a great plain crowded with monsters. I fly in search of a partner (women only) to be equipped with. Magic stone? I get the skills I absorb? This has become fun! Hyahha, give me magic stones! Yes, that was a joke. But I’ll take a magic stone.

This is how I became a sword and went to another world, a story of an ordinary minor character otaku.

I Was a Sword When I Reincarnated (WN) average rating 4.2/5 - 452 user ratings
Associated Names
One entry per line
Tensei Shitara Ken Deshita
転生したら剣でした
Related Series
I Was a Sword When I Reincarnated (LN) (Light Novel)
Recommendations
I Reincarnated Into a Vending Machine (8)
Kumo Desu ga, Nani ka? (2)
Spirit Migration (2)
The Elf Is a Freeloader (2)
If It’s for My Daughter, I’d Even Defeat a Demon Lord (WN) (1)
Re:Monster (1)

Latest Release

Date Group Release
12/13/17 CardboardTL c140c140
12/11/17 CardboardTL c139c139
12/11/17 CardboardTL c138c138
12/08/17 CardboardTL c137c137
12/03/17 CardboardTL c136c136
11/30/17 CardboardTL c135c135
11/27/17 CardboardTL c134c134
11/23/17 CardboardTL c133c133
11/22/17 CardboardTL c132c132
11/15/17 CardboardTL c131c131
11/13/17 CardboardTL c130c130
11/11/17 CardboardTL c129c129
11/09/17 CardboardTL c128c128
11/06/17 CardboardTL c127c127
11/04/17 CardboardTL c126c126
Go to Page...
Go to Page...
Write a Review
36 Reviews sorted by


saihamaru
New saihamaru rated it
November 30, 2017
Status: c120
This is an enjoyable read. Not the best out there, but certainly entertaining enough for me to write this review despite my sh*tty english (do hope you forgive me for that)

The setting of this novel is pretty unique compared to other reincarnated/isekai stories i've read:
First of all, protagonist choose to stay as weapon instead of trying real hard to get humanoid form. Sure he have a way to get humanoid form, but author decided to give huge minus on that method, so MC rarely use it. As result,... more>> he's not mindlessly building harem.

The sub-genre is pretty diverse... so far we have power leveling arc, dungeon crawling arc, detective arc, and even some cooking competition arc. It's hardly getting boring with all of that. It's just... the author sometime jumped sub-genre too suddenly that some chapters feel detached from the main story.

The supporting characters are pretty well defined too. They don't feel like just a side character whose reason being there is to make MC look strong. I really like it when we get their PoV chapters, too bad they're very few in between.
Spoiler

i especially liked that certain chamberlain chapter

[collapse]
Though some mob characters certainly feel too forced as evil. But their idiotic evil act is indeed amusing to read as MC proceed to punish them.

Last but not least, even if you think MC and heroine pair is overpowered, they always manage to find an even stronger adversaries that they have a hard time to deal with. These fights often led them to use tricks and even then, they win just barely, shounen-manga style. I personally prefer this to MC steamrolling everything with his godly strength. It make the powerleveling chapters feel worth the while. <<less
0 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
ieh
New ieh rated it
November 28, 2017
Status: --
I tried really hard to like this story after reading the first ~3 chapters of the manga. Story takes off when he meets Fran a child catgirl slave whom he decides to help to make her dream of evolving, which her parents died trying to accomplish.

However, the story falls a bit flat because before the MC even met Fran he killed and stole the skills of one of the most dangerous and high level monster infested area. I really wish it focused more on Fran since she's a catgirl from... more>> a fantasy world and not another Japanese guy who died from a car. I want to learn more about this new fantasy world and how it works not about the weird hang ups from otaku Japanese sword dude.

I wish the sword wasn't so OP in stealing all the skills and giving it to the girl. I wish it was more creative with the skills used and wasn't so on the nose and brute forced. The skills and abilities feel a bit earth shattering and made up as the story goes along. I find the sword and the girl's relationship to be quite cute and hope it doesn't go down the lolicon route.

My biggest problem with this story is just that the tone is all over the place. Like some other reviews mentioned, the catgirl is sometimes kind and a child while other times a merciless killer who tries her hardest and at times is really self motivated. The MC is a loner otaku that doesn't trust anyone except when he meets cute girls or the story needs him to. Lots of wasted potential in this story for me. <<less
1 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Neutralensig
Neutralensig rated it
April 22, 2016
Status: --
This is just a partial judgement from me, Ensig, who just finished translating C13 and is sleep-deprived at 3:30 AM.

All reviews posted on this Novel (prior to April 22, 2016) other than Raphael’s (which makes a fair point) are complete bollocks. Yeah. Bollocks. Those three reviews judge the Novel based off of the first 10 Chapters (or less), even though the real action starts to kick in at about C11, C12.

Not giving it more breathing room than 10 Chapters considering its length would be the same as denying a good... more>> 80% of Novels the time to become “good” as well. Things have to be explained and foundations need to be made — and that takes time. Thus, the reason why I called their reviews bollocks.

As for my thoughts regarding the story: 4/5. It’s definitely not Excellent, but it’s not “meh” either. It’s just “good”. It’s definitely not Overlord quality, and it’s not like it smacks around Goblin Kingdom or Re:Monster, or any other Item/Monster reincarnation story either. It fits right in the middle. It won't be a story that you'll jump up and down in excitement for whenever a Chapter releases (or at least not so far), but at least to me, it's sort of like a finding a cookie sitting out on the table; it's a pleasure to find, but it's not like it'd kill you if you didn't find it.

As Raphael stated, reincarnation into a Monster/Item is becoming increasingly common, but I just like the idea of the MC being a Sword that can move itself around. It’s unique. Will it always be unique? Probably not.

But for now, it is.

I recommend giving this a read, not because I painstakingly translated it (I’m doing that for my own entertainment to curb off boredom), but rather because I think at the stage it’s currently at (C13), the story is just getting warmed up. And I can’t wait to see where the Author’ll go with that heat. <<less
80 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
mllhild
mllhild rated it
July 28, 2016
Status: c180
First, ignore the cover image of the LN, its brings totally the wrong image to the story characters.
Spoiler

Like what the hell is Fran wearing?! She owns and wears nothing but armor in the story.

[collapse]

Second, read the first 20 chapters (they are short so no problem) before commenting or deciding how the story is. Not everything has to start with a meteor shower, truck-san or a pair of boobs
Spoiler

no ecchi for you here, only gap moe

[collapse]
. Maybe 11 chapters of a sword explaining the abilities and showing the mind, weaknesses of the MC could help the world building.

I liked it enough that it became the first WN where I read the raws until the latest release and now have started to translate it together with ensign.

Bad points first:
- the MC goes sometimes on to ramble
Spoiler

(well, he only talks to like 3 persons in 180 characters so of course he talks to himself)

[collapse]
- short chapters? At least this means it will be released more frequently
- has only the most necessary world building
- very few POV chapters (I really like this kind of chapter)

Good points
- good pace
- MC is a sword, so NO HAREM
- no MC solves everything alone,
Spoiler

or even cares to

[collapse]
- no moral pu**ys
- Fran
- Fran's dialogues
- Fran's grandiose speeches
42 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
CaptainToast
CaptainToast rated it
May 14, 2016
Status: --
I tried to get into this novel, but I really just couldn't. I'm probably leaving too early as I only got to chapter 12, but the story is boring. It might get better, but the first 6 chapters are translated horribly, and the ones that actually were translated decently are just plain boring.

The main problem I had with the story is the plot itself. A flying magical sword by its lonesome is interesting for about 30 seconds before it becomes ridiculous. Maybe my initial thoughts on how it should of... more>> gone are ruining what's actually there. A more interesting novel about a guy reincarnated into the legendary heroes sword and their journey to save the world would be pretty cool. But even if this eventually starts to be like that in the distant future, it's already ruined.

What had to kill the novel for me after a bit is the sword's utterly ridiculous skill stealing ability. It reaks of bad story telling. In review, don't bother reading this. As of right now it's nothing but a huge disappointment. <<less
25 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
dtim
dtim rated it
September 9, 2016
Status: c21
An extremely generic reincarnation story. Replace 'sword' with 'slime' or 'dragon' and you wouldn't be able to tell any difference. You might think that a sword as the MC and being wielded by a girl would be unique but in execution it's not any different than any other MC encountering a girl and having her join his party. There's no creativity to be found here.
18 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Raenef
Raenef rated it
April 19, 2016
Status: --
Hey, I am a sword!
A wielder?
Not needed!
As I can fly and steal abilities...

Yawn somehow not original and boring after 7 chaps no reason for an op sword or mission....
17 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Queen Oceananas
Queen Oceananas rated it
May 5, 2016
Status: --
I am not good at reviews, so I will keep it short. I love this novel. Yes, it is not that far along, and yes, the first eleven chapters or so are kind of boring. But I have some experience in novels, and I see a lot of potential in this story. So, if you would, give it a read, like, follow, comment, whatever floats your boat. It might just give the translator some more motivation in pumping updates out faster. (The translation speed is not that slow, but I... more>> had to try, you know?) <<less
13 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
lunati4ko
lunati4ko rated it
August 22, 2016
Status: c20
As of chapter 20, all I can say is that I am disappointed. So disappointed in fact that I decided to leave my first review on this website.

Premise (4.5/5) :
... more>>
Spoiler

Main reason for my disappointment was this premise raising my hopes. When have we ever seen a reincarnation in an inanimate object. This was so full of opportunities for entertaining and awesome developments... Wasted opportunities

[collapse]

Plot (1/5) :
Spoiler

O boy where do I even start. First 10 chapters were like reading the activity log of an mmo character. MC defeated X. MC gains Y skill. Awesome. (Won't even start on the author giving a stat page after every chapter - Tell-tale sign of a storyteller that has no clue how to convey progress in a meaningful way, so they 'statify' it)

Then we have the pacing. The author has his priorities upside down here - He spends 10 chapters on a menial grind, then he rushes all the character development in 2 chapters. It is like he has no clue how to do meaningful character interaction so he fills the novel with fodder.

[collapse]

The characters (1/5) :
Spoiler

The character development is almost zero. Sometimes it is actually making the characters flatter than they already are. An example that comes to mind is the main cool parts of the MC is him being an inanimate object and how that hinders him in his life. So what does the author do, he gives him telepathy and a way to make a body (clone) for himself

Character interaction/dialogue is even worse. The has been 0 meaningful dialogue in the first 20 chapters. The characters feel flat and emotionless. Their reactions to amazing stuff are almost laughable. Like for example MC and his wielder (12 year old girl) save a peddler from goblins. Like imagine a 12 year old obliterating

5 goblins asap. And the peddler is like 'cool, thanks'.

[collapse]

Overall this novel might as well have been written by a middle-school student. From the start it is very apparent that this is written for the enjoyment of the author and not for the reader. <<less
11 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Hamsta
Hamsta rated it
September 30, 2016
Status: c53
3/5

Mediocre. Read if you have free time.

Basically a dimwitted otaku meets truck-san (car-san here), reincarnates as an OP sword, lives his new life like a derp learning mmorpgs, & wielded by adorable slave neko-girl.

... more>>
Spoiler

Surprisingly being trapped alone in a magic-free zone for 3 months actually made him less retarded.

[collapse]

The characters are..... plain. You have the OP moronic MC, the hyper competent sidekick w/ tragic backstory, freaky strong dragon err..."spirit" chick. Along with the archetypal support crew (kind-hearted merchant bro, wise ol' dwarf blacksmith, kindhearted receptionist-san, intimidating but softhearted guild-bro, smart glasses elf, etc), & a host generic villains to keep the action flowing (no primary antagonist as of c53 other than possibly the divine swords that are all "mysterious" and associated with massacres).

Truly a sad waste of a unique premise. (They honestly should've never given the MC telekinetic powers right off the bat. Or at least kept it severely limited instead of having him almost immediately solve all limits of his 3 minute flight/mana consumption) Currently he's just a generic OP reincarnation novel protagonist that has to hide his true form.

Spoiler

Seriously, a better way of setting up the first ~15 chapters: MC reincarnates as a sword --> Gets wielded by a goblin who he really dislikes but has no other choice (because he's literally a sword) but can't do anything about since he's getting exp/skills/stones --> Goblin becomes the strongest in his den & ventures out due to overconfidence (or tricked by MC into going out) --> Goblin gets too cocky and killed by another stronger creature (cannon turtle or whatever) --> Gets knocked away by the blast & accidentally kills a floater creature granting the floating skill --> MC starts life as a slowly floating spell casting intelligent sword --> start of the rest of the story.

[collapse]
<<less
10 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Axelord
Axelord rated it
July 27, 2017
Status: c72
Four stars across the board.

It's seriously well rounded on all fronts.
Isekai, OP, all the shebang and yet it's still worth it. Majorly. Author knows his tropes and clichés actually like to play them on and off almost randomly. Some of it's taken straight, other times they are subverted so you really can't figure out exactly how stuff'll go around the next corner.

MC and MCette really do well together, although I wish (personally) that the Sword would use one of his ''fleshier'' skill more often. Cat-people are made to be... more>> pet and there's a definite lack of hand-on-head action in this (so far).

Spoiler

Only gripe, at this moment, would be the translation that got picked up in April of 2017. I had some minor issues beforehand but [Comet Translation] couldn't translate his way out of a German McDonald drive-tru with the correct amount of mcnuggets. Heck, he'd probably make his getaway with a slice of pizza, somehow! It's become a chore to read from Ch67 and onward. Newcomers beware, you might as well just google translate the raws yourself because that's pretty much what you're getting anyway.

I won't take any stars off because it's definitely not the fault of the author that it's become that bad but if I had to take the current translation as a whole I'd be very much tempted to dock a star, or even two. So, I'll be putting this in my [Ketchup] folder for now and wait either for [Comet Translation] to up his ball pitch or for someone else to pick up. All the better if the quasi-botched chapters are redone.

[collapse]

If you're looking for a good power-leveling isekai with half-n-half amounts of seriousness and lightheartedness, then this is most probably right up your alley. <<less
6 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
SUBSIDY
SUBSIDY rated it
January 6, 2017
Status: c54
It's a tips bit disappointing, kinda feels dry at times, and a bit forced, but overall... Disappointing

Well... the first few chapters were good, but when the MC meets the heroine (wielder) he pretty much gets chained down, kinda like she's holding him back from going full power... adventure with a slice of life kind of feel?
6 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
UnknownSaint171
UnknownSaint171 rated it
May 22, 2016
Status: c31
This is a very good story. I think the Synopsis needs to change since it makes him sounds too lecherous. The Main Character is very caring and he feels like a Father. Its really funny and heartwarming. Seeing the MC grow stronger is very entertaining. Despite being a Sword he still acts very Human. He still takes the Main Role!

The second Main Character is a Kuundere Cat Girl Loli! Its definitely worth reading! Her goal is as the weakest beast race is to evolve. I hope he can evolve to... more>> a Human too though sounds impossible.

There are flaws here and there but that's only normal as a WN right? Some things don't make sense and could definitely be better so I rate this 4 stars! Still definitely one of the best WNs I've read. You can't stop reading <<less
6 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
keklel
keklel rated it
July 25, 2016
Status: c33
Swordbro isn't the best reincarnation novel out there, but I wouldn't say it's bad. It's way better than Re:Monster (which I think is garbage) but not on the same level as Reincarnator (a masterpiece). Sometimes it presents the story from perspective of other characters such as the kuudere lolicatgirl, and it has good story focus so it doesn't ever feel boring unlike certain novels (e.g summoned slaughterer).

Characterization is not that bad. If you simplified it you could say the MC just wants to eat powerful monsters and kuudere lolicatgirl... more>> just wants to evolve or something well she doesn't really talk much. So the characters are arguably pretty bland but they do get fleshed out here and there somewhat. What I'm saying is that the characters actions are consistent and make sense and not stupid. Well the main draw of the story is the plot rather than characterization and forget about MC's past life, he doesn't even mention it past chapter 1. I won't say much about the action other than that it's pretty standard xuanxia stuff - use skill, BAM enemy dies, gain new skill repeat ad infinitum. But the story progression so far is pretty interesting, it definitely feels like it's moving forward and not just slaying the same monsters over and over since he keeps getting new skills which significantly impact the story. Well it's only been 33 chapters so it might get boring at some point, we'll see if the translator keeps it up. <<less
5 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
TokenZero
TokenZero rated it
May 15, 2016
Status: c27
Okay the first 11 or 12 chapters are all background/building chapters where the sword starts to become familiar with his surroundings and gain skills and power ups
... more>>
Spoiler

because you see later that his attack alone isn't even a match for common steel swords and daggers, so he actually needs quite a bit to set off

[collapse]
.
The story picks up after he meets his owner and travels to a town so that his owner may become an adventurer.

There they learn various things about the world, trying to find out where he came from (who made him), classifications of swords and whatnot and begin the life of an adventurer.[As of chapter 27]

As far a characters go even though some of them are quite cliche like the elf guild master and dwarf blacksmith even one has there own unique personality and so far none of them are just there to be a peanut gallery.

In contrast to what other people thought of the first 11 or 12 chapters, I actually quite enjoyed reading them probably because 'Game Elements' novels are my favorite types but also because this is probably the only novel I have read with a non-living protagonist. So I was just wondering how a sword could do things all that time without bothering to think of whether it was repetitive or 'boring' <<less
5 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
nin
nin rated it
August 25, 2017
Status: c79
The first 12 chapters are readable, but they are pretty cliche. It's just a typical OP protagonist in a JRPG style world story, except that the OP protagonist is a sword. Any novelty that comes from the sword aspect wears off pretty fast, and the fact that there are a trillion skills to keep track of even early on doesn't help matters much.

Once the sword meets its sword master though, the quality of the story rises dramatically. It's overall a pretty much a slice of life adventurer story, but the... more>> main protagonist bounces off the deuteragonist (loli cat girl swordwielder Fran) extremely well. They have a sweet father-daughter relationship going on, and the generic personality of the swords develops to be a bit more fatherly. In contrast, Fran is a stoic badass. The side characters aren't really developed much, but the dialogue the main two characters have with the side characters is consistently entertaining even while the novel is world building.

The flaws of the OP protagonist style story are mitigated by the fact that Fran is vulnerable without the sword and that the story is about making her stronger rather than just making the sword as OP as possible. The character Fran has a clear motivation to get stronger (fulfilling her parent's wish of a successful evolution) that the sword is convinced to help Fran in. There isn't much of a plot otherwise, but it's sufficient for holding the story together. The world building is also pretty interesting. It's not 100% original, but I like certain takes the author has on typical JRPG cliches like dungeons.

Overall, it's a pretty well executed isekai story. There are better ones, but this is still higher enough above average to warrant checking out. <<less
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
ProsciuttoApathy
ProsciuttoApathy rated it
October 11, 2016
Status: c54
Feels a bit like a fluffier, less philosophical version of Kino's Journey with the reincarnated character playing the role of the sentient inanimate object. While nowhere near as classy as Kino's Journey, at least the main duo are visibly changed by there experiences even though it's mostly just leveling up their stats.
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
scribbledoutname
scribbledoutname rated it
September 16, 2016
Status: c48
Really enjoying this :D

I'm not sure what people mean by the first 11/12-ish chapters being boring, because I enjoyed them (I like watching characters exploring on their own and acquiring skills/getting stronger). The chapters are quite short too, so it's not some long, tedious read. It would only be boring if none of it was building towards anything... but fortunately it is: from chapter 12ish (can't remember the exact chapter), Fran shows up and the story gets a direction. The character interactions are enjoyable and the slowly growing cast is... more>> fun to watch. Plot developments also happen frequently enough to keep the story enjoyable, and both Fran and Sword Bro's personalities create some enjoyable chemistry.

Five stars up to chapter 48 :) For the rest I'll have to wait and see. <<less
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Pulsing_Pressure
Pulsing_Pressure rated it
May 20, 2016
Status: c30
Slow start but don't let that deter you from reading this, the story is building itself nicely and
Spoiler

the story finally picks up the pace when the MC find his wielder

[collapse]
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
admira
admira rated it
January 26, 2016
Status: --
Somehow, this novel feels pointless. Or maybe "plotless" would be a better description? Events happen, but even by stringing together a good number of chapters I can't find any point to them all.
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Raphael
Raphael
November 2, 2015
Status: --
This theme (of reincarnation as something like an item or a monster) gets more and more broad yet for some reason I feel it shrinks with every new novel...
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
justice41
justice41 rated it
June 15, 2017
Status: c71
2/5: Near Average
Premise is good, quite unique and striking MC (Fran and Teacher) but why I rate it 2/5... well sort of it has few issues.. mostly on the author....

First the first few chapters was way too fast of a development for the sword, even though the intention was to be an OP, it's pretty plain and dull. No further explanations and just poof... OP sword

Second might be to the inconsistent characterization. On analogy, if you portrayed a stoic, anti-social like MC (Fran) you should stick to it while... more>> adding few char. developments as story progresses. But.... this doesn't happen here. It's quite the reverse, OP sword gets more char. dev. than Fran.

Lastly, unconceivable setting. If you introduced a society with political plots and manipulation, and have an MC with anti-social and trust-issues (once a former slave), be thorough with it. If I'm the OP Sword "

Spoiler

Why the hell would I say to reveal that I'm an intelligent weapon to someone who I just met a day ago, quite bullsh*t. Didn't I came to thought that person would secretly say it to the higher ups? Way too trust in this kind of setting.. Why the hell would I openly enter the scheme of the Guild Master when I have felt it moments before... Why oh why for the sake of plot it was made like this, damn author.. oh went 4th wall break.

[collapse]

So as of now it would be 2/5.... don't get me wrong.. the series is good, even the manga (though it felt rushed).. but it lacks careful writing preparation and suffers potential plot holes and no end goal, rather feels slice of life than adventure...
Nevertheless I highly recommend it for a good read... <<less
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Leave a Review (Guidelines)
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.