This is a story before my pet is holy maiden timeline featuring the elf El's past life when she's transported from another world to earth. Mostly fluffy slice of life fantasy meets modern world setting, with some bits of romance, a relaxing story. The MC is a little bland though, the usual Japanese nice but bland teenager; El and the side characters are the one making the story moving along. There's romance but it's not the focus of the story until near the end of the series and wrapped up... more>> rather quick. It's quite a short novel ending at chapter 55, it's a decent read in short time. <<less

Interesting premise for sure, but -1 star because:

A typical dense retard MC who doesn't even know wtf an elf is, thinks it's the name of an alien star where she's an alien who came on an alien spaceship. What. The. F**k. Even though she looks like an elf wearing leather armor like an adventurer and all, and he even saw her pointed ears. It practically screams fantasy, no where is it anything close to sci-fi.

This right here, what's seemingly a minor thing, is an early warning sign about the MC... more>> and story, already enough to deduct points.

Edit: This is getting pretty boring. I prefer this story more "When I Returned From Another World I Was A Silver Haired Shrine Maiden". It's similar but feels more realistic and have better reactions. <<less

Why is this novel recommended on so many novel's pages?? How can a story with only 16 short chapters translated deserve so many recommendations across such a wide range of novels??

After reading the available chapters, I can only guess someone is going out of their way to get this novel recommended on as many other novels as possible just for kicks.

... Not that the story is bad or anything, there just isn't much substance to it as of now. Hard to know whether the story is decent or not when... more>> we've barely met the characters. <<less

It's just the Author ideas are good but the Characters are very bland. It's the same with My Pet Holy Maiden (with superficial characters.) Though it's Entertaining, that's all there isn't to it. You can easily get bored with this since it's predictable... Obviously Aoi isn't the best girl here.

I don't have much to say since everything been said if you scroll down but.. the Dad pretty much Coerced them to make her an Idol. Which is pretty stupid logic. It's like the Author ring to keep it Realistic and... more>> Drama while ignoring the Fantastical aspect of it as much as possible. Nothing really planned. Just short and entertaining but boring at times.

-Big Breast girl beautiful but stupid but this one is Beautiful Elf girl who instantly falls in love with MC. Give them a bit personality and better setting, why don't cha? <<less