Broken-Winged Angel


Links are NOT allowed. Format your description nicely so people can easily read them. Please use proper spacing and paragraphs.

Shi Qing Xia is practically an angel.

Kind, sweet-hearted, and good at her studies, she was admitted to the top university in Taipei.

However, the living expenses for the metropolitan city were far greater than she had ever imagined, so she started to work as a private tutor for wealthy families to make ends meet.

On her first day of work, she met Zhao Yi Bo and Zhao Yi Xuan, a pair of neglected 16-year-old genius twins whose prosperous and wealthy parents heartlessly abandoned in Taiwan. Shi Qing Xia found them to be gentle, compassionate, friendly, clever, mysterious, pitiful and attractive.

But appearances can be very deceiving…

Because behind those sweet smiles…

Deeply twisted and cruel demons lurked, waiting to rip apart the wings of this angel, condemning her to an eternity of conflicted bittersweet suffering — a rollercoaster ride of a heart-wrenching, twisted, and tragic romance more extreme than what someone so innocent could possibly imagine.

Associated Names
One entry per line
Related Series
Gratifying the Royal Family (4)
Taking My Elder Brothers As Husbands (4)
Sickly Tyrannical (3)
The Men at Her Feet (3)
My Beastly Husband (2)
Crossing the Crowd to Chase Love (2)
Recommendation Lists
  1. Novel That I've Found Good and Damm!!!
  2. BG/BL - Oblivous/Naive/Idiotic/Simple MC
  3. Future Reading (Yaoi, Shounen ai)
  4. Oops! Scenes prohibited for minors! (Adult, Mature...
  5. Books to be read

Latest Release

Date Group Release
04/13/20 Novice Translations c56 (end)
03/14/18 Ainushi Translations c55
03/14/18 Ainushi Translations c54
03/14/18 Ainushi Translations c53
03/14/18 Ainushi Translations c52
03/14/18 Ainushi Translations c51
03/14/18 Ainushi Translations c50
02/17/18 Ainushi Translations c49
02/17/18 Ainushi Translations c48
02/17/18 Ainushi Translations c47
02/17/18 Ainushi Translations c46
02/14/18 Ainushi Translations c45
02/14/18 Ainushi Translations c44
02/14/18 Ainushi Translations c43
02/14/18 Ainushi Translations c42
Go to Page...
Go to Page...
Write a Review
38 Reviews sorted by

New Dragon_Reader rated it
May 11, 2020
Status: Completed
The MLs should die a slow, painful and horrific death.

I can't really find faults in MC coz she does try her best to run away but she just can't coz she is too weak. Physically, status-wise. Frankly speaking, her mental strength is pretty great considering she doesn't go crazy and stab those two bastards to death or suicide.

Crap book. Great translation for a crap book.
0 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
sushi roll
New sushi roll
May 3, 2020
Status: Completed
Before you read this please do be mindful of the tags, if you aren't comfortable with any one of those then I suggest you skip this. It must be because I've read materials that had events that were much worse that I wasn't really bothered while reading this. Setting aside the thing that happened to the MC, I would've liked it more if the author delved more into the thoughts of the characters, like, how exactly did the brothers fall inlove with her? What were the key moments? Clearly it... more>> didn't start on the event of the butler's death but way before that. Maybe its just my personal preference but in the case of novels that has themes like this (obsessive love, abuse, stockholm syndrome, etc) I think it would be much better if authors gives a huge emphasis on the characters' mentality and their thought process. It just my cents though. Anyways, , , it was a decent read, not too bad in quality. <<less
2 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
October 29, 2017
Status: Completed
A Sadistic Fairytale?

... more>>

I’m a simple girl. As long as the guy (s) are loyal. I iz fineee!

The Male leads, as much as I hated them, they are loyal and they have have a sad past. ISH. The character development is 😍🙏🏼👌🏼 HUGE as they will compromise for our female lead. They will control their temper and adjust. I mean they do have anger management issues but they will learn to control it.

Our female lead is ok. She’s quite realistic and her character development is ok. She will learn how to TAME them. She will learn how to lure them. Like for example, how one time she got pregnant and the male leads wanted an abortion as it might be harmful for her and she’s like “abortion can be bad for my heart AKA ABORTION MIGHT HURT/kill me” andddd she ended up keeping her baby because the guys are scared of hurting her in any ways.

Their first baby (boy) is a mama’s boy. He hates/is scared of his fathers and is also possessive of his mother.

There will be a second baby (girl. Both children are always forgotten because the male leads would think and pamper the female lead. 😂
Overall, it’s a 4.5. Not perfect but not bad and is definitely Good (for me). TOUGH LOVE! Enjoy!😍🙏🏼👌🏼

40 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Fathom rated it
October 10, 2017
Status: Completed
I suppose it's an easy read, but not really a comfortable one. I was expecting a smexy smutty romance story. This one isn't really it. There's not much consensual smut going on. And the smut going on isn't particularly romantic or sexy either. The deeds get done without too much fanfare on emotions or feelings. Kind of reminds me of those anime hentai one shots. It's got several stereotype kinks, with twins, an older female tutor, bondage, some violence, and some aphrodisiac drug usage. At no point did I feel... more>> there is any love in any characters. The twins have a massive obsessive complex and don't seem to care about the main character's feeling at all. Instead of trying to romantically pursue her, they would rather just imprison her and r*pe every day. Really the only escape method is to suicide, which is such a cop out method.

Overall, it's a boring read, if at short one at least. Not a good story even as a smut one and definitely not a romantic one. It feels very amateurish and not descriptive on any details. <<less
27 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Selene-Rhea rated it
October 1, 2017
Status: c10
I like it so far it's fresh and something I haven't seen much of.👍 It's also sooooo...... twisted. Is it bad of me if say I actually like the twins.😍
20 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
September 30, 2017
Status: c10
Yo, I seriously thought the twins have become twisted because their parents have shitty personalties. But no~pe.

They've been twisted since forever.


Before you read this, read the tags. Everything that you might encounter in this novel is clearly stated in there. If you don't feel comfortable with even one of those, don't read it. Just don't. I can't give it a clear rating yet until I've read more. And yes, I'm still reading it. (Not good with giving reviews but I just gotta say it.)
15 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Hitexh rated it
December 28, 2017
Status: c29
If you like to watch japan porn, you will enjoy this. Putting MC in the position of victim has its own appeal to some fetish. Because I have seen life worse than MC had and how society works, I believe the MC is still quite fortunate. Some who disagree and seek a perfect happy MC please find other novel.

In my opinion, the twin has every right to abuse her because they also offer their finance. I know I am a kind of person who is willing to sell my soul... more>> for money. But with this fact, I know the twins are not 100% bad people. If I were MC, I will demand them to give me more freedom and give them reasons logically. If they dont listen, lets suicide together. Lol. So far, the MC doesnt dare to reason with them due to his fear from their first crime. I guess MC is not smart enough, she has money, she can even buy lubricants and aphrodiastic to make their intercourse less pain if she can expect it unavoidable.

If I have 2 waifus who are like them, I will be happy being ravaged by them. Even if its 2 hubby, I bet woman is willing. <<less
10 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Aisiteru rated it
January 11, 2018
Status: c34
Maybe there are other violent and abuse MC by ML novels (moreover, it's 2) out there but this is my first time read one and it is this story.

I feel pretty bad and anger but addicted at the same time. The twin characters are very twist but they still have love for MC. Moreover, they slowly develop to be better on how to love MC. BUT then MC was the one trying to find every faults in around her and give it to both twin even though it's her friend's... more>> or her own fault, she just push them to MLs, omg this is unreasonable la.

Not that I'm a masochist but after reading till this chapter, I found that the twin are not bad at all, very loyal and protective to MC, apart from the violent s*x parts, they offer everything else to her with both hands only to get her love as a reward. <<less
9 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Berlin rated it
May 28, 2019
Status: Completed
Admit it, you're here for the smut or BDSM vibes. Nothing wrong with it, a fantasy's not reality. Trust me, if I were to meet such MLs in real life I'd run faster than the ugly new Sonic movie. And this story wins in that writing - a guilty pleasure read. It's what this is.

I like it cause the author doesn't shy away from how problematic the relationship was with a HE and wool over the MC's eyes. In fact, the tragedy makes it all the better. I would have... more>> rated this badly if it ended up with them living happily ever after. But it only turned out f*cked up, precisely what it should be. The genre should be horror psychological drama more than 'romance'.

I would have liked it more if

the red herring Yuri pair which was actually sweet, turned out to be endgame. Or if she managed to escape or kill/jail the twins.

7 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Meera Ran
Meera Ran rated it
January 19, 2018
Status: c34
I like this novel. It’s not angst that much, it’s more like male leads are too possessive toward MC. They are jealous when MC talk to other than them. They are loyal to her and love her much. That’s why I love this novel. Twins are not bad they just don’t know how to properly love MC because of their tragic past and abusive past. What I like this novel is about their loyal toward MC. I enjoying reading this novel.
7 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
K_araxx rated it
October 6, 2017
Status: Completed
It's a good story there's very little drama though so if you're expecting some deep plots and drama there's really none of that. It was a quick read and the ending was kind of funny I guess. It wasn't bad but it wasn't a novel you would remember for that long. It's a good read if you're bored though.
7 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Shinygold13 rated it
March 25, 2018
Status: c55
The premise is promising but the execution was lacking. As a person who reads smut, even dark ones, I never shy from anything taboo and the idea of this novel is truly enticing, so exotic in fact that I read this while waiting for my flight and here’s my verdict:

  1. Too much time skip
  2. Narrative seems to be summarized probably in order to fit its 56 chapters (though this may just be my own perspective) but it IS still a good narrative, it’s just that I could not immerse myself fully and at the same time, couldn’t experience the emotions/actions supposedly being shown by the MLs
  3. Quality translation! This is commendable (I wouldn’t mind reading other books that will be translated by this group)
  4. Insufficient character development and why, for me, the ending seemed hurried.
  5. The MC’s emotions and actions are spot on as I find myself agreeing with her POV, her struggles and the overall realistic feel she oozes (the author must have experienced this, read a lot of books of this genre or a very down to earth imagination)
P.S. It’s in first person
6 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Chan2 rated it
May 17, 2018
Status: Completed
I won't recommend this short story unless ;-

1. you have nothing else to do.
2. there is no other reading material out there.
3. you are into Japanese porn
... more>>

I read till the end becoz I was curious about the ending. However the ending was a big let down. The ending was so abrupt. It seems like the author is in a big hurry to finish the story. There is no plot......

The two ML are so twisted. Their lifetime aim is raping the MC. There is zero character development for ML, MC and side characters.


The only saving point is the translation. The translation team did an excellent job. <<less
5 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Maiasia rated it
October 3, 2017
Status: c38
MAJOR EDIT SINCE CH. 10 (AND CHANGE OF OPINION) : As of ch. 38 I've put this novel on pause. I don't really like where the story ended up. She wants to escape the twins yet at the same time she's actively enjoying them spoil her. I mean, I wouldn't blame her for reaping the benefits of their possessiveness if done in a smart way but I feel like it was poorly done, as though she was a spoiled princess who had return from her tiny bout of rebellion to... more>> lavish in entitlement that the mouth says she doesn't want but the body says otherwise. I feel like if she couldn't resist them physically, she should had resisted more emotionally and mentally, but that's not how it is. The way it is at the moment makes me feel like she's sending mix signals, like, I like you but I don't like you, or like, I-don't-want-this-but-I'm-not-really-going-to-resist-with-all-my-might-because-deep-down-I-might-just-like-it, which annoys the heck out of me. You either don't want to stay (so please put your all into escaping) or you do (so please find a nice middle ground for your threesome). Not mentioning the botched blackmail attempt, which was poorly done on the heroine's part (roll my eyes), and the only two times she actually tried to escape and failed, I feel like she's not that bright. She knows how crazy they are about her yet she doesn't use it to her advantage. They obviously give her whatever materialistic things she so much as hinted at and yet she's never tried to bargain for a little more freedom. I'm sorry but I just can't bear to continue on. I can accept amateur writing, no one starts out writing fluid stories, and I like the psychological aspirations of the story but the characterizations irks me. I feel like the plot is not fleshed out to all its potential and the writing is not thoughtfully done as to draw the readers into these "poor, unfortunate" souls' world but instead it feels like the writer just wants to move the plot along so the story telling ends up being cold and emtionless. I like the twins but they could be developed deeper, I've read worst non-con but steamy scenes could be steamier or at least more emotionally charged, and I'm not a fan of the heroine. She doesn't have to be smart or clever or even talented, she can even be a push over but at least make her charismatic. Sigh. I'm sorry but my initial 3 stars is dropping down to 2. I appreciate all the hard work of the translator (s) but this review is solely for the story itself and does not reflect in any way on the translator's abilities. This story just doesn't have enough oomph for me. I might pick it up again somewhere down the road because I am a yandere-con but at the moment there is not enough chapters to make the blah of the writing worth reading. <<less
5 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
FaerNC rated it
January 28, 2018
Status: --
This story is definitely not one about the sex, go read something else to fap to, this story is about the torturous life of a woman subjected to possessive and abusive twins who love her to bits, but won't stop to hurt her, cripple her if she acts out of line. This story focuses on the psychological, the clear display of bipolar disorder within the twins, and portraying the horrifyingly effective results of the twins' acts upon our female lead, from a slowly constructed stockholm syndrome-esque mindset and a conditioning... more>> to become a slave. Definitely not for the softhearted.

I must say it is also quite saddening that the first chapter had already shown that she will have no happy ending, locked and used as a thing by the twins, borrowed from the harrowing beginning of Shakespeare's masterpiece Romeo and Juliet, two lovers doomed to die. (Is this review professional enough for you?) <<less
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
July 27, 2018
Status: c55
Not giving it a rating, tbh I guess its mere morbid curiosity that had me reading it to the end so it's not fair for me to rate something that's outside my area of tolerance.

The translation was well done.

The protagonist is too soft-hearted imo, Stockholm syndrome for sure.

... more>> The male leads are yandere, the harmful kind... physical abuse/torture, non-con, and extremely paranoid.

I guess you can say I'm very vindictive, if death is what it took to escape them, then I would do it... living such a way akin to being a mere tool for lust and being abused on top of that despite their claim of love... that's just beyond the realm of acceptance IMO. <<less
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Kiera95 rated it
July 11, 2018
Status: Completed
Please don't waste your time reading this... why you ask?
... more>>

1. No character development, the characters are all so consistent throughout lol.

2. There is no closure to any issues presented. And mind you, those issues are dark mofos. This just shoves the reasons behind why this novel plot happened the way it did into a neat little pocket of nothingness. P.S. The twins just remain psychotic their own lives.

3. MC seriously has a case of Stockholm's syndrome, but she didnt seem truly in love at all. She eventually just seemingly gave up on life and went along with the flow.

4. Ending was the worst ever like what is that cheap imitation of an ending.

I just wasted an hr of my life hoping to see the light in this novel. Don't be stupid like me :)

3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Ukimi rated it
June 28, 2018
Status: Completed
Read the tags before reading the novel!!

Reasons why I gave it a 4/5

  1. The ending felt a bit rushed.
  2. Lots of time skips.
  3. Felt that MC didn't "love" them, its more like she got used to them.
  4. Some side characters that were there in the beginning just never appeared again towards the end. (Just gone lol)
Other than that, I thought the story was great. As I mentioned before, read the tags before reading the novel. There is a lot of sensitive scenes that might trigger people (i.e. abuse, rape, etc). I personally... more>> enjoyed the novel very much, I found it very 'refreshing' and different from the typical stories that I read. And by 'refreshing' I mean there is practically no drama in the relationship; no side-chick, no rivals, nothing; just MC and the MLs (Compared to other novels that are full of love rivals and schemes/plots). Any "love rivals" will get kicked away by MLs lol. It's pretty much a straightforward story.

This is a mature/smut genre type novel so expect a lot of snu snu.


If you just want to skip to the first s*x scene it's on ch 8.

I have to say that the boys are really forceful and hardcore too (depending on who you are)


Talking about bullet point number 1 & 2:


The ending felt a bit rushed because of all of the time skips (in the beginning she's 18 and by the end, she's 41). That made me confused bc one day she's 20 and the next she's 30 with a child. Like.... wut? I'm serious though, a lot of time skips towards the end.


Talking about bullet point number 3:


There was a point in the novel where she ran away and slowly realized that she actually loves them. But right before she decides to go back home they find her and chain her up in the basement so she'll never run away again. And honestly, I wished that she realized her feelings and went back home sooner or for them not to be so harsh on her; because after they did that to her, her love and all the other emotions she had were gone. She basically became an emotionless s*x doll & MC just accepted her fate and stopped resisting them. I really wanted her to love them, not get used to them. :/ At the end of the novel (when she's 40ish) she loves them (or so they say) but I didn't see anything that would lead to that. Maybe it happened during the time skip, but they should show that to the readers at least. I can't just assume MC ended up loving them if I didn't see anything.


Talking about bullet point number 4:


An example would be MC's best friend. She was by MC's side during college, supporting her and everything. Then she slowly fades away after graduation and completely disappears after she gets married, never to be mentioned again. And the doctor she meets in a village, he only appears twice and was last mentioned chasing a nurse? lol


Do I recommend this? Yes, but not to everyone.

Do you have a fetish of absolute sexual dominance? Go on right ahead 100%.

Do you enjoy soft fluff and MCs hugging full of affection and them confessing their never-ending love to one another? Nope, go away. No room for you here. <<less
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
CuteReport rated it
May 2, 2018
Status: Completed
This is sick but I really enjoyed the story.
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
weirdreader rated it
August 17, 2019
Status: Completed
It's hooking from the prologue and you want to know more, but it's abusive not (mostly) sexually, it's seen as a punishment rather than an enjoyment it's scary to be honest.

... more>>

The ML leads try to change but even at the end they are very controlling and always try to dominate the MC, they don't trust her words easily, (I guess due to the fact that she tried to escape, who wouldn't?), I don't blame her actions, they are reasonable and realistic


With the ML leads, one point you want to kill them and another hug them, you literally have a battle within yourselves on whether they are good ML leads or not. <<less
2 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Tikkitumble rated it
April 13, 2018
Status: Completed
***3.5 stars***

How do I put this? I enjoy the somewhat short length of this novel, but I must say that this is one of those novels where you anticipate things getting better, only to be horrified that it really doesn't.

It's like watching a train wreck. Entertaining train wreck, but a train wreck nevertheless. Once you start, it's difficult to peel your eyes away from the story, even though some of it makes you want to give up entirely. If you can get through the tough plot line ... more>>

like actual rape-r*pe (it's not pleasant to read) and physical abuse (how about imprisoning MC in a basement for half a year), Stockholm sydrome symptoms, sadism and battered women syndrome

, you will be able to finish the story. However you will be raging through it all. To make it worse, the story doesn't really have redeemable MLs. They care about her, of course, but they don't take redeemable action. Not until the end of the novel do we get some respite, but that's only during the ending. The female lead pretty much gives up fighting them and surrenders... which means no actual character growth from her captors. I'm still suffocating for her up until the very end. She accepts her fate and the obsessive control over her life by her husbands which is masqueraded as love. In real life this is plain abuse. But in fictional fantasy mode, this is not too out of the ordinary. Read at your own risk.

This book is only worth 3 stars, but the translations have been done very well. Everything flows and not many mistakes. So I give it an extra 0.5. <<less
2 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Warui rated it
April 4, 2018
Status: c55 epilogue
Look at the tags; All the bad thing there are done to the MC by the two male leads.

I'd feel bad rating this lower because of all the work put in by the translator.... but this story was completely unenjoyable for me. Almost every chapter made my cry out of anger. I'm here because I like yandere, but the 'yandere' was not convincing for me. I'm not into sadistic characters, I'm into excessively passionate characters. Rather than being so obsessed they were crazy, the twins are just abusive, unfeeling people... more>> who got attached to someone.

They never apologize, nor do they feel regretful enough to move me. They finally worry about her near the end and she feels vindicated after being a tiny bit manipulative. Oh man, you made them a little worried, that totally makes up for all the times you ended up hospitalized.


she ends up completely hating them, with like a little bit of love left. She gets a tiny smidgen if freedom decides to use it to spend the rest of her life manipulating them to make them anxious for her. Hon, it's gonna take a while for that to add up to revenge for months of being treated like a s*x doll. (Not slave, doll. As in, they only interacted with her to get off, and ignored her the rest of the time. Leaving her literally strapped to a bed in an empty room.)


(spoiler isn't huge, just details a few things and talks about emotions at the end).

If you're into NonCon, there are a few steamy scenes. But the second half of the story is infuriating and I found it impossible to enjoy. Even taking into account how Chinese romance typicality wants a modest girl who's embarrassed by sex, everything was about they guys' pleasure to a disturbing degree. Just know what you're getting into, ok? <<less
2 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Leave a Review (Guidelines)
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.