I'd say 4 stars for the cute, but it's Christmas so I'll gladly toss in the bonus.

It's a very cute, very sweet, Christmas story that would have Rankin Bass, Frosty the Snowman, and the Winter Warlock all giving it a thumbs up. Rudolph well to borrow from the story

"He’s kind of annoying, but he’s funny."

If you need a shot Christmas schmaltz this will do the job.

There's only one minor issue I had with the story, I believe "Gnomes" should have been translated as elves.

There is not much to add to the review done by kawaii12345. The rating is, of course, very personal, but compared to other, similar short stories, I'd say, no more than three stars for me. Mainly because the story telling is so all over the place and difficult to follow. The conclusion is still very clear and the moral of the story heart warming, so just give it a try, especially during the Christmas season.