Winner Takes All

Description

Links are NOT allowed. Format your description nicely so people can easily read them. Please use proper spacing and paragraphs.

A fickle, decadent, wilful person going through life like it’s a game.

An experienced, logical mind that’s above feelings.

This was a relationship that had started off with “Carpe Diem”, but slowly turned into a bloodless, psychological battle. They shared a mutual distrust, but also mutual attraction. As they suspected and tested each other, challenging each other’s limits, they both fell into the enemy’s hands with their eyes wide open. Sentiments growing amidst ignorance, they finally, were caught in their own traps.

Winner takes all,

Loser stands small.

Associated Names
One entry per line
Ai Đem Ai Là Thật
Shéi Bǎ Shéi Dàng Zhēn
Who cares
Who Takes Who Seriously
谁把谁当真
Related Series
Years of Intoxication (Shared Universe)
In Love with an Idiot (Shared Universe)
Professional Body Double (Shared Universe)
Beloved Enemy (Shared Universe)
My Little Poplar (Shared Universe)
Sissy (Shared Universe)
Additional Inheritance (Shared Universe)
Blazing Armour (Shared Universe)
Alpha Predator (Shared Universe)
Grey Uncle and the Mixed-blood Prince (Shared Universe)
Recommendations
Intoxication (1)
Recommendation Lists
  1. tbr danmei
  2. To remember
  3. Angsty Danmei (BLs)
  4. F*ck my life .
  5. Modern day Danmei

Latest Release

Date Group Release
08/08/24 KnoxT c114
08/07/24 KnoxT c113
08/06/24 KnoxT c112
08/06/24 KnoxT c111
08/13/23 KnoxT c110
08/12/23 KnoxT c109
08/11/23 KnoxT c108
08/10/23 KnoxT c107
08/03/23 KnoxT c106
07/27/23 KnoxT c105
07/20/23 KnoxT c104
07/13/23 KnoxT c103
07/06/23 KnoxT c102
06/29/23 KnoxT c101
06/29/23 KnoxT c100
Go to Page...
Go to Page...
Write a Review
28 Reviews sorted by


Acidelia
Acidelia rated it
April 25, 2020
Status: Completed
Short summary of the novel: Turbulent. But absolutely worth the read.

I like the MC, he's mature and principled, tolerant and kind - and those strengths of his also appears as his glaring weakness, but still he learns and actually reflects from his mistakes and actions. I think his character was well written. And I actually really like how author writes about other aspects of his life, beyond his relationship with the ML, in the text.

The ML, on the other hand, has got me sooo conflicted. He's a thrilling character in... more>> MC's life, one that certainly tests his boundaries - both in a good and bad way. Good, in that MC's controlled character can finally express what he's always repressed and never dared to do. Bad, in that his later actions in the text is sooooo scum-like I hoped that he'd be more emotionally punished (though I might also be influenced by all the scum-abusing novels I've read lately). I mean he protects the MC, but also low key takes advantage of his kindness.

Like author's other works, the question of whether the MC should forgive the ML for what he does is certainly gonna be a point of conflict for readers. Most will definitely get mad, but some may also forgive him. If you can ship author's previous pairings in her old works, you can probably tolerate this one. I personally wouldn't but I'm not the MC. Still, he's not intolerable and definitely should not the reason you avoid this novel. Please read it, I want to discuss it with others too.

Whether love and relationships, should really entail losing your mind over someone depends on your views and I think that's something the author also highlights through the difference in views and behaviours of the MC and ML, and their ability to compromise and be together despite that.

Also I have to call out that the side characters actually have purpose in the text. It rarely happens so I feel the need to point it out T-T. Like, for all the various characters that are introduced, they all add to the text and are not merely passerby who are later forgotten. MC is so lucky to be surrounded by good friends and a supportive family, and he knows and appreciates that.

Overall, I can see the author's experience writing dogblood novels here, it is well-written with well-fleshed out characters and a frustrating drama and relationship that compels you to continue. I personally think this was better compared to author's previous works because it had a less scummy ML and a more rational MC, making their HE more acceptable. <<less
28 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Psychoutre
Psychoutre rated it
May 30, 2021
Status: c52
I've made an account solely to leave a review on this novel.

Feeling pretty let down seeing that I enjoyed the initial premise of the story, the characters were fleshed out well and I liked the whole chase and run, but wow. I should've seen the signs that this author really loves their male leads that hold no respect towards their partners and had never heard of the word "consent". I've just about had it when the male lead wouldn't stop at 'no'... but to take advantage of the MC in... more>> his drunken state not once but freakin twice!?!? Goodbye.

It was a good read in the beginning but I can't force myself reading all toxic levels of red flags anymore. All the male leads from their own respective novels mentioned here can only be described as crazy, controlling and creepy. All the shous including the MC were losing brain cells by the minute by continuing their association with these men. What they need aren't prayers but restraining orders. Honestly is everything okay at home author?? <<less
27 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
creeture
creeture
January 27, 2022
Status: c96
I love Li Shuo, so I was delighted he got his own romance story. As someone already states, it has less angst than the other 188 novels, which is great, although I do love angst. I also think it has a very happy ending.

Since no one has mentioned this, I'll say so. There are a few instances in this book where the author uses racial stereotypes that can be a bit...offputting to some readers...I'm talking about portraying the few black people who appear as criminals or mindless antagonists. As a... more>> matter of fact, while I've never experienced racism in person, based on the region of the world in which I live, it was very triggering for me and some of the other readers, especially those of us who are black from different parts of the world.

I'm not telling anyone to boycott the book or Shui Qiang Cheng. I've seen quite a few of these portrayals in even some KDramas, and I understand that a lot of this is heavily based on ignorance in Asia about how certain groups are portrayed in Western, particularly American media. I've quite literally had people surprised over how 'posh' I've sounded because they clearly expected something a bit more unrefined because of my race.

However, I mentioned this because I think people deserve to know and be aware of something that might have a negative impact on them mentally. I love her books, yet it mentally affected me to the point where I had to put this one down for a few weeks before I could continue with it. I know I wasn't the only one. <<less
23 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
KaliBones
KaliBones rated it
April 19, 2022
Status: c92
This is probably the only SQC novel that I genuinely dislike, borderline hate. Only reason I give 3 stars is because I read the tags and knew what I was in for given how SQC writes.

The tag "Character Growth" is 100% false.

... more>>
Spoiler

ZJ is absolutely irredeemable. He approached LS under false pretenses and colluded with his cousin to ruin LS business causing him to lose millions and eventually he had to leave the company he built. All so ZJ could help his cousin take back LS boyfriend who he was abusive to.

[collapse]

Spoiler

ZJ stalks LS by tracking his whereabouts, makes a copy of his house key and follows him everywhere to embarrass and humiliate him if he thinks LS is with another man.

When LS over hears ZJ telling his cousin he is using LS and basically just wants to f*ck him and making sure LS wont take revenge but will throw him away when he gets tired.

ZJ has the nerve to be upset that LS doesn't want him anymore and acts like a victim while also blackmailing LS into being with him by threatening to send LS Dad to jail.

ZJ lies continually, so LS never knows when he is telling the truth.

[collapse]

LS IQ just reduces as the novel goes on. There is no character growth of ZJ, zero, zilch, nada.

Spoiler

ZJ never once apologized for the horrific things he's done which included raping LS while he was drunk.

By the end of the novel LS just became s*upid and knows he shouldn't be in this relationship but he "loves" him even though ZJ told him that he would ruin his families life and even lock him away just to have him.

ZJ never learned his lesson At all. He wasn't remorseful until he knew LS would fold and come back to him just because he got stabbed.

[collapse]

The story boils down to someone putting up with a narcissist emotionally abusive partner just because the D is good.

If there was character growth I would feel better about this novel but there isn't.

Spoiler

This one of the few novels where I wish the characters did not end up together.

If this was real life ZJ would probably end up mu*dering LS because if he cant have him no one can. The rest of us would be listening to his mu*der case on a podcast talking about how sad and horrible this person is.

[collapse]

I love novels with scum gong, angsty etc.. But this just made me want to scream. The best part was when I was done reading.

My Little Poplar has one the best character growths she ever wrote. So I'm actually surprised this story has zero. <<less
16 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
FrostyDragon
FrostyDragon rated it
January 2, 2022
Status: Completed
4 stars because Shui Qian Cheng's writing is impeccable.

One of my least favorite 188 books (probably because it has less angst), but still good. Li Shuo doesn't take sh*t from the ML, and Zhao Jinxin knows that he had better behave in the future.

Li Shuo is the second ML in both Sissy and Additional Inheritance, and the MCs and MLs from both those novels are supporting characters in this book. Shao Qun is still a scum, Luo Yi is still a psycho (but Xiaohui has him on a... more>> leash). Xiaohui plays a big role and is still adorable. In this book Li Shou finally gets his own romance, and he's close to the perfect love interest. Calm, collected (well, most of the time, since the ML does manage to rile him up), mature, successful, kind and considerate to lovers, friends and family.

Zhao Jinxin is one of the least scummy MLs in the 188 series, and like all the MLs, he's mostly an idiot in love whose actions hurt himself as much (if not more) than they hurt the MC.

Personally I wasn't as engaged in the MC and ML in this novel compared to most of the other books in the series, but one scene did stand out to me:

Spoiler

When Li Shuo tr*shes the hotel suite he has previously lovingly decorated for Jinxin's birthday, and has a rare emotional breakdown, it hits so much harder because of how he's normally such a calm and collected character. Later on, when Jinxin accidentally sees the hotel room with the destroyed decorations, he finally realizes just how much Li Shuo loves him and exactly what he's lost due to his own spoiled, malicious actions. It's truly heartbreaking.

[collapse]

Winner Takes All contains some spoilers for Sissy and Additional Inheritance, so if you're already a fan of the author and can stomach lots of angst and very scummy gongs, I recommend reading those two first - they're relatively easy to MTL. Otherwise, this novel might be a good place to start if you want to try the series and the 'wife chasing crematoriums' trope, but aren't used to stories that are heavy on dubcon/noncon and ab*se. This book is definitely one of the milder ones, although there is some dubcon (I slightly disagree with the 'rape' tag, but I get why at least one or two scenes can be interpreted that way).

For readers who can't stomach lack of consent - don't read this book, and stay away from all the other books in the 188 series. The author doesn't glorify dubcon, noncon and emotional or physical ab*se, but it features heavily in a lot of her stories, and while this is milder, it's no exception.

About 'wife chasing the crematorium and 188 series: the books usually have this structure (sligth plot structure spoiler:

Spoiler
  • Nice and kind (often slightly older/mature) MC shou meets villainous ML gong
  • ML and MC get together and the MC pours all his love and care on the ML
  • ML turns out to be scum and does something unforgivable to the ML and betrays his trust
  • MC finally has enough and leaves
  • ML realizes he can't live without the MC
  • ML chases the MC, sometimes going full yandere and doing crazy things to win his lover back
  • ML finally persuades the MC that he truly loves him and regrets his past bad behavior, often through an act of putting himself in danger for the MC's sake
  • MC and ML get back together and have a more balanced relationship. Happy end.

Lots of angst, emotional suffering and dogblood tropes.

[collapse]
<<less
11 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
urmigg
urmigg rated it
October 11, 2023
Status: Completed
From now on I will try to not be negatively influenced by the reviews and I suggest you do that too. Influenced by some of the reviews I hesitated reading this but thank god I read it eventually. This is my favourite work of the author, after reading this, I beacame fan of her works. Many reviews said about many negative characteristics of both the ML and MC which (some of those traits) are big turn offs for me but after finishing the novel, I could not relate to those... more>> reviews, like how is li shuo always guilty and self blaming? I don’t see it. So everyone's way of thinking is different, so don’t get influenced by the negative reviews and give this a try.

One thing for sure this novel will not bore you, this was a rollercoaster of emotions. ML was an a$sh0le to MC and he regreted, the regret arc is one of my favourites. Well, MLs are all a$sh0les in 188 universe. Toxic? Yes but we are immune to toxins <<less
9 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
orztodaempress
orztodaempress rated it
February 17, 2022
Status: c5
YESSSSS!!! I can't believe how well-written this novel is!! I've been sleeping on this gem for so long~! T^T

I always used to look for novels with the tag "manly gay couple" and have yet to come across a novel which actually kept up the pretense of the tag after the MC and ML met, so I gave up... Until this novel!! Wow, I was actually genuinely confused who the gong and shou would be. And even when the shou was revealed, I honestly would've been genuinely surprised (along with the... more>> shou himself) if not for the translator spoiling the tidbit about the gong and shou's age gap.

Spoiler

Li Shuo's entire body stiffened. Staring at Zhao Jinxin in disbelief, he felt as though he had been struck by a bolt out of the blue.

He had never expected that Zhao Jinxin, actually, wanted to f*ck him?!

[collapse]

Pfft- I love the revelations that happen in BLs that foreshadow their s*xual awakenings (✧≖ ͜ʖ≖)

And the translation is impeccable. Fluid, no obvious grammar errors. I even feel like this novel was originally written in English, I'm learning so much from this as a writer. Even though I'm only on the 5th chapter, I can tell this will be amazing. <<less
8 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
rosierosie
rosierosie
May 9, 2020
Status: --
I'm currently on CH 25 with Eng translation, and I love it. The story is intriguing, exciting, and interesting. I love how MC is so filial piety towards his parents, and how he has a good head on his shoulder. I like how our ML is so forward, blunt and feisty. At this point, it seems like ML is scheming with his cousin, maybe the ex-bf of MC's lover??? But we shall see who's going to be the winner in the end! Thank You for your wonderful translation, and I... more>> hope we will get to read all and finish this novel together^^. <<less
8 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
DaraLyne
DaraLyne rated it
December 21, 2022
Status: Completed
I'm gonna say this, you can either like this or straight up hate it, there's no in-between. There is no true Villain in this book, every character is written with a story, course of action and principle, which allows readers to understand their actions. It is a heartbreaking book. But I will still recommend reading it. There's so much that you can think about whilst reading this book. Especially, if ZJXs actions towards LS is really love and if anyone will appreciate being 'loved' that way. Also there's the question... more>> of of ZJXs inability to recognise his emotions really an excuse for him to treat LS how he did. Mind you I went into this book totally blindsided! I was 20 percent into it when I realised ZJX had 2 different personalities but ultimately I got to understand why. But sis, if you meet a man like ZJX irl, please run... unless you can in LS's terms, "tame him" <<less
6 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Staringatastar
Staringatastar rated it
April 23, 2022
Status: Completed
My fat fingers! I meant to give this a 5 stars, 5/5, great read! Instead I clicked 3 and can't seem to change the rating now 😭

I loved this story. I thought I would only read a couple of chapters since I got to a boring part in another novel, but then the s*xual tension and drama and characters just kept me going.

I agree with the translator, this author writes wonderful novels about relationships that real people should use as templates for what not to do. However, the misunderstandings and... more>> conflicts sure make for great tension and engaging story.

I agree with the translator - while the ML does some things with bad intentions initially, he's not that bad compared to some of the other ml's this author dreams up. I honestly thought it was intriguing how he had so many sides and behaviors depending on the situation. <<less
6 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
King of No Killing
King of No Killing rated it
December 8, 2021
Status: Completed
What can I say? I'm really bias when it comes to Shui Qian Cheng's novel. I love how dog-bloody it is and how the MLs would grovel before the MC with their pathetic and crazy self. This one (Winner Takes All) is just like that. But well the a**holeness is a bit lighter compared to SJH from Years of Intoxication. So here the ML thought he has the upperhand in playing hearts but damn was he wrong. And so the chasing began.
6 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Onelazygirl
Onelazygirl rated it
October 9, 2022
Status: Completed
I am really curious that how can the ML be so coldblooded and sees feelings as game

Like since he was doted on and pampered. His parents are so good to him, so how can he be this heartless???

I quite like this novel, I will not comment on the dogblood as the author has a certain reputation of writing particular type of scum gongs

... more>> I read this willingly have no complains, then why didn't I give 5 star rating you ask??

Because one thing that really pissed me off was that

When the MC can't even bring himself to kiss someone ML is full on banging different people every single day since they separated.

If anyone still have doubt about the ML's character then let me tell you he is a motherfu*ker.

He is such a bastard that if I will meet him in real life I will beat him black and blue

He obviously long overdue a good beating

I really agree with what the MC said that the ML came for him because he could not let go of such a gentle and meticulous partner, he did not necessarily came for love

He didn't want to let go of the gentleness the MC had the pure pampering

He knew no one will treat him as well as the MC does so he traps the MC by his side

One thing that is actually so funny is that the villain saved the CP's relationship from further worsening. Like literally villain saved the day 😂😂 <<less
5 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
rimirinrin
rimirinrin rated it
February 16, 2022
Status: Completed
I've read this after reading Sissy and Additional Inheritance because I NEED to see Li Shuo's HE. He's such a charismatic and gentle character and I really love him.

I like the interaction between Li Shuo and Zhao Jin Xin as they're very raw and flirty. Both are not afraid to voice out their likes and dislikes. No awkwardness or anything.

... more>>
Spoiler

However, some of Jin Xin's actions mirrored Shao Qun's actions from Sissy so much that I really hated him at a point. After all his redemption period I really felt his emotions and love that I began to forgive his character. After all, he's also a spoilt kid as mentioned - his father had him late and overprotected and doted on him too much. Also, I like how the book ended well with marriage and happily ever after. I shed tears of happiness at the proposal and marriage "ceremony".

[collapse]

Great book! <<less
5 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
nyxzane
nyxzane rated it
July 20, 2021
Status: --
i m die hard fan of shui qian cheng and have read all the novels. its true ML is always black belly and MC suffer but despite being a black belly when turned love sick ML is then the most loving caring just like a golden retriever following his master (MC) around.... and yes that golden retriever is a jealous type always eating vinegar 😊
5 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Winterrz
Winterrz rated it
October 7, 2022
Status: --
OMG it was so good at first that I thought the negative reviews were baseless. But sweet Jesus does it get terrible!!!

Basically the ML is in a relationship with an unwilling older man still in love with his exes. Base.

So yeah, it's good the first few chapters, but don't let that fool you. The chapters after are so full of drama you'll think you're reading a highschool romance.

MC is too obsessed with his ex's. OMG he's like their little guardian and knight in shining armor, move on already!! MC ignores... more>> ML too much. And this, to me, makes the underhanded efforts of the ML to get the MC justified. Otherwise we wouldn't have a novel to begin with; MC is just too obsessed with his ex's and would rather be with them. So many times I just wish for the ML to move on, but no; the whole point of this novel is him forcing a relationship.

It gets really cringe. I wish I had the power to choose my own mains when reading novels. Such a waste of time!! <<less
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Po Yun
Po Yun rated it
September 24, 2022
Status: c19
The translators deserve a medal and many big hugs for willingly subjecting themselves to this literary dumpster fire.

This is the same author, who penned "Beloved Enemy, " a novel two-stepping on so many red lines that Texas Rangers might as well have been on standby. Yet, infuriatingly, it came out victorious. In no one's defense, certainly not my own, I have guiltily devoured "Beloved Enemy" four times. Each reading took place at different stages of my young adult years, and while I concede that it doesn't hit the same at... more>> 22 as it did at 18, the novel still keeps its head above water. Shui Qian Cheng weaves enough charms for the world-building and characters that it almost — almost justifies the questionable aspects of the story.

Shui Qian Cheng - bless her heart - aimed to replicate this success with "Winner Takes All." You know the drill: Write a novel that could get you arrested in multiple countries, then attempt to distract us with her linguistic prowess. Well, if that was her intention, she failed. Spectacularly.

Winner Takes All starts by hammering home the main character's intelligence, with all the subtlety of a reversing dump truck. Except, this is the same character who could have a truckload full of red flags marching towards him at neck-breaking speed, and he would still gently inquire if it is attempting to make eye contact, because - and excuse my French - the man is remarkably dense.

Though, I was well-prepared to take a hit on the IQ front for the sake of the plot. This dude clearly needs a significant drop in IQ points for the narrative to function, despite the author insisting otherwise. What I will not accept is the sheer audacity of writing a character so mind-numbingly boring, it makes staring at paint dry seem like a front row seat at a Beyoncé concert. She somehow, through sheer misfortune or whatever, managed to check all the ultimate cardinal sins boxes. Hence, in the most respectful way possible, lukewarm is how I feel about this dude. While I don't necessarily hate his guts, I wouldn't willingly subject myself to whatever the hell - is going on between him and the other dude, unless forced at gunpoint.

Speaking of the other dude, his love interest - or perhaps more accurately - love disinterest? Another classic case of a failed attempt at charm. Now, this one, I absolutely despise. This love interest is supposed to be the Yuan Yang (the insufferable anti-hero we all love to dunk on) of this story. Except he only came with Yuan Yang's obnoxiousness and NOTHING else. Yuan Yang, insufferable as he may be, still has redeeming qualities, even if they come as rarely as a snowstorm in the Sahara. There is just something about him that convinces me he could be a main character of a fictional world, one in which authorities are too busy taking vacations, and jail is basically a myth.

This dude? Oh boy.

Never have I felt a stronger urge to deploy the cringe emoji in a review. Mr. Love Interest - and this is where Shui Qian Cheng fumbles the bag - is so utterly devoid of personality, it's hard to believe he was crafted by the same mind who did Gu Qingpei. The Gu Qingping that was, for the most part, the saving grace of Beloved Enemy, yet according to Shui Qian Cheng, Mr. Walking wet sock is the most sought-after bachelor on the planet, and judging by the narrative's relentless attempt to assault us with how charming he is, he might as well be the second coming of Jesus Christ. But the evidence to support this claim? Gone! Like Amy Dunne. Non-existent! Like Jeff Bezos's hair. Disappeared! Like Elon Musk's compassion. Vanished! Like the protagonist's common sense. (And yes, I can do this all day)

While I wasn't suicidal enough to slog through ten more chapters of this tedious charade to unearth his "mystery", and the sheer inconsistency I've witnessed is enough to assure me that whatever it was, it definitely wasn't worth the torture. The entire relationship, from what I managed to stomach, was basically Drop Dead Gorgeous Genius Boy Number One getting bamboozled by Billionaire Boy Toy Number Two (aka Mr. Disinterest aka a walking empty shell) eleven years his junior, into some sort of sadistic abusive, Stockholm Syndrome situation. And if you start asking pesky questions such as why? How? - Or - for the love that is all logical - ELEVEN YEARS?! Well, congratulations, you have just put more thought into this story than the author.

Oh, did I mention the age gap? The author never lets me forget it. Every two minutes, we're reminded that Mr. Genius is significantly older than Mr. Personality Vacuum. This information is delivered with all the subtlety of The Weeknd's performance in The Idol - a lot of impact but ultimately meaningless.

And I'm not taking lightly the heavy topic that was presented. It's the half-handed way Shui Qian Cheng tackled it that gains zero sympathy from me. Suddenly, and because the plot said so, our - once again - decade-older - rich - genius - experienced - cunning - drop-dead gorgeous protagonist - who could have anyone in this world - decided to check out his common sense at the door, replaced by a brain so lobotomized he sees a rusty, dented bucket with a hole in the bottom and thought, I'll take that. So, we, the unfortunate readers, had to be subjected to a discount-store version of a damsel in distress, tossed back and forth by the narrative so admirably dull, Vanilla would be jealous of its blandness.

And their chemistry? Spare me. It's about as present as the concept of shame in the US Congress.

Winner Takes All feels more like Shui Qian Cheng's vanity project, created to pat herself on the back for her specialty in writing angst, than a story worth reading. Essentially, it's a yawn-inducing conflict between two painfully dull people, and a potential jail sentence waiting to happen.

So if you don't identify as a masochist, go to your room, lock the door, and read Beloved Enemy. <<less
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Lea168
Lea168 rated it
April 30, 2022
Status: Completed
4.25/5*

I love the author and have read almost all the 188 series.

This novel is in same universe as Sissy and Additional Heritance. Sissy was written first and they share a parallel timeline, but the world building feels different because this story background is partly in the US. There are some changes to events what happened in Sissy but didnt happen here. Also the MC now has a different personality than the minor role he played in Sissy. It is not bad, but if you read this story directly after Sissy... more>> you might need to adjust a little bit.

I cant really explain why, but maybe this story was not as tragic as Sissy was, this story left less of an impact than the other SQC stories in this 188 series did. Though the MC here is definitely one I like a lot. He is smart and rich too. So, the power balance is somewhat equal. ML could only be a relatively normal scum.

Both MC and ML had much experience when it came to past relationships. Its a mature story and very much this authors style, which I love. <<less
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
yaoi.danmei.bl
yaoi.danmei.bl
March 14, 2022
Status: --
Bro this ML does not know to back up. There's something wrong with his head. I swear I cused him so many times in chinese while I was reading this

Alright now I feel bad for the ml, he liked MC so much and tried so hard to make MC happy and was so excited to do anything with MC. However, every single time he's met with cold ruthlessness. Although ngl he deserves it lol
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
acquiesceu
acquiesceu rated it
August 1, 2024
Status: Completed
Mmm I can see why people have conflicting opinions about Li Shuo.

(note: most my review will be about the characterization instead of the plot. if you know what you're getting into reading this, then the plot will be expected and/or average considering your liking for the characters. I recommend reading the caard 188 info for TWs because I see a lot of reviews upset over them)

If you read Sissy first, you may have a positive surface-level impression of him, but in Additional Inheritance I feel like readers fall... more>> in love with his character more. When I saw a comment of how some people didn't like Li Shuo, I figured it must have something to do with his own book, and now after reading I understand why.

After being familiar with his noble character and strong morals, kindness, and clear boundaries, seeing Li Shuo's own POV is just too contradictory to what was shown before. Maybe that can be attributed to Zhao Jinxin's appearance, but the principles of the Li Shuo in this book don't exactly feel like the same principles of the Li Shuo in the other books. The excuse of being tossed around and allowing misunderstandings is Li Shuo's fear of his own ego... but it's just hard to accept that reason for the sh*t he had to go through.

Zhao Jinxin... really deserving to be Shao Qun's cousin. I love to hate both of these guys, because it feels like they never truly learn their lesson. Do they understand why what they did was wrong? Do they understand the behavior and actions derived from the behavior towards the person they love is wrong? We don't see Zhao Jinxin's POV that much but his actions lack... sincerity. Both of these brothers just have a go-go-go mentality of getting whatever they want no matter the cost. At least Luo Yi (supposedly) has the decency to watch from afar after f*cking it up big time! All three of these MLs end up going to the ICU for their MC (either trying to protect them, prove something, and/or take advantage of the injury to win their wife back) and each time it causes their respective MCs to turn over a "new leaf" and give another chance. It kinda annoys me to death but I digress, it's what I signed up for.

Spoiler regarding the end:

Spoiler

The proposal left me bittersweet because although I love that the characters I've followed are all gathering together, if I was in Li Shuo's shoes and saw how the proposal was mirrored just like how Zhao Jinxin's birthday room was, I would have been distraught. Seeing how ZJX kept the little lamb toy was moving but... for some reason it felt like that "confession." I don't know, I just have mixed feelings even if this novel has less dog blood than the rest.

[collapse]

There's not a strong sense of side characters in this novel and we're mainly following Li Shuo alone. I don't know if that was intended, to indicate how Li Shuo prefers to keep his problems to himself, but it left the plot feeling a bit flat for me. I still love cute Xiaohui's appearances though haha.

Lastly... I'm a bit unsure if this is MTL that's currently being edited as I write this. Just that I noticed some sentences were missing or mistranslated. For the most part the translation is alright though, just rough in some chapters. Also the smut chapters in the airplane/wedding night extras are censored, so you'll need to look at the raws for those. <<less
2 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
NYQ83
NYQ83
January 11, 2023
Status: Completed
This one I liked the most, and so far I read Sissy, Beloved Enemy, and this novel. I wish I knew that some novels in 188 series we’re connected in ways like for example Sissy and Winner Takes All. While reading this Novel I was so glued to it, and I really did not want it to end, definitely gave me a teary eyes at the end from happiness. I do wish that s*x scenes were more in details, because I felt that they were lacking in that area. Overall... more>> great story, excellent structure, and beautiful ending. <<less
2 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Leave a Review (Guidelines)
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.