Rushed and not ideal of an ending, MC chooses the wrong best girl (I felt that the kouhai's only selling point is that she'd care and go all the way and for him bc she likes/took an interest on him), his past bullies apologizing out of nowhere, their guilt is apparently big enough that they would do that much effort, idiot sister doubting the MC in the first place, annoying that she's going full oni-chan on him are just some of my rants

Ending was so rushed that we were unsure what happened to the girl in the title of the whole novel

Emi has so far been doing nothing to redeem herself or make herself look like a decent human being. She has broken down multiple times when seeing the MC for some odd reason (Shouldn't it be the opposite). I assume it must be because of trauma. As of ch. 12 (the whole reason I wrote this review), in this extra chapter showing her pov, it would seem that she has princess syndrome. She acts dramatically most of the time, and when she gets in trouble she expects to be saved by a dashing man.

Once she sees the eyes of the MC, she gets a flashback of a girl who killed herself in middle school and they had the exact same eyes. So she decides to help him

forget about everything and live with mc

after their father passed due to a car accident going to mc's soccer game she became cold and distant. After a while, she began blaming the MC for their father's death.

Shuya was completely cucked in one of the worst ways imaginable. Of course, this is where the copy paste comes in. Dude is gloomy, pessimistic and is the guy to bottle up his emotions. But that isn't to say there aren't a lot of other genres that have copies of each other. It works in Shuya's case because after you hear what he went though I'd also probably be the type who'd just give and and just go with the flow as well. While I understand his reasoning behind staying away from Maika, I think he should've gone with his gut feelings of her having good intentions to let her help him. I think she should've been a bit more persistent with trying to help him, but I guess at the end of the day it would've just caused more problems than solve them. I also didn't really like how he continued to self loath while none of it was really his fault. His mother's neglect wasn't his fault at all. It was her fault for not taking care of her child and not realizing that 'fake smiles' totally exist. He was literally putting on a smile for Sachi's sake and she completely ignored that possibility. Now Shuya is a bit more energetic and has become more open to those around him. Of course he's not forgiving many people yet. but he understands they want to help him get out of his shitty situation after they showed him where their loyalties lie and their true feelings. Now he's super confident and just doesn't give a flying F*ck about Emi or her boyfriend since he basically has a backpack full of metaphorical nuclear weapons ready to launch the moment they step out of line.

Honestly I was expecting Maika to become his love interest but I guess since she semi basically gave up on him after he told her to mind her own business basically said he wasn't going to develop any sort of feelings for her any time soon. The Love interest being his Junior makes a lot of sense to me since they spend a lot of time with each other and she constantly got mad of his sake and had his back even before she knew what really happened and the fact she only reinforced her loyalties to him afterward just makes you scream 'put a ring on this girl immediately'.

Now Emi... Now I get that she's still a victim in some way, but she mostly stopped being the victim after Shuya moved away. It completely makes sense that she'd be traumatized and mentally damaged after going through that and being forced to bully Shuya. But instead of solving this problem by exposing the bullies and properly apologizing on her hands and knees to Shuya. All she does is threaten them slightly and made a run for it. Then after that instead of moving on with her life like Shuya obviously wanted to do. She spread bullsh*t for no f*cking reason other than to secure her place as someone who can't be bullied. She plays the 'damsel in distress' you'd expect in princess stories. She even had the nerve to be distraught when she dramatically tripped in the hallway to get Shuya to help her but he didn't do shit. This girl is disgusting. Even her closest friends have basically given up on her. Itakura is basically the only one who's semi on her side. I can totally understand her point of view and the fact that she still cares for Emi despite knowing she has done something unforgiveable. I think she understands that what Emi needs is help aside from punishment. Emi needs mandatory therapy. In fact it was shocking that she wasn't already in therapy after what happened. As for Emi's future, she's probably going to remain as a mentally unstable mess if not she's going to completely snap. She knows she's already backed into the corner but still is playing the victim card while saying those around her are selfish. She's going to try something and force Shuya's hand to set off one of his many nukes which will obviously finish her. He doesn't want to do that though. He knows that Emi is a screwed up girl but wants her to fix it, get help just like Itakura wants, and move on with her life.

Itakura was kind of surprising to me. I mean it was obvious from the start that she was the one spreading bullsh*t about Shuya. But what I'm surprised about is how easily she switched gears. But Frankly I'm also disappointed because she should've known instantly who was her imposter. Who is she closest too to get her information? Who gains the most from putting Shuya's reputation into the dirt? Any guesses? of course it's Emi you freaking dolt. But I guess they realized that rather quickly after the meeting. As for Itakura's future, she'll probably spend most of her time trying to fix Emi unless after Emi snaps she may just give up on her.

Maika's future? We more or less went over her stuff throughout the review so I don't really feel the need to cover her, side from her sense of justice that everyone knows is pretty accurate. Which is kind of a head scratcher because then you'd think that people would start to question why she's suddenly on Shuya's side. I definitely would realize something's fishy and ask her myself, though she'd probably just tell me to mind my own business -.-As for her future. I'm guessing there's a slight chance she'd end up with that guy who has a crush on her, but I doubt it considering what he's done to Shuya. She'll probably stay in the friend circle with Shuya while reluctantly promoting the love between him and the JR.

Kana was also a surprise yet not a surprise. A lot of people have been approaching the MC out of guilt and curiosity I was surprised that she'd spend so much time gathering evidence and was bold enough to confront one of the original bullies and get him to confess basically. Dude is still a dickbag BTW. But if Shuya uses the recording he'll get what's coming to him I'm guessing. I'm not sure what she'll do after this, unless we go full harem status and she starts advancing on Shuya I'm guessing she'll probably just return to minding her own business.

As for Shuya's future. I'm guessing he may just follow in his father's footsteps while going out with the JR. Going through college and stuff like that. Of course he's done with just standing by while people belittle him so I'm guessing the second Emi provokes him he'll bury her under all the evidence he has and that'll be the end of it basically with him not really 'being bothered' by it as he always been doing.

I think the approach is rather semi realistic. I can understand people's wanting of drama, of the thing blowing up. For The villains to get their just deserts. But I think just trying to get them to just drop it and move on is probably the more realistic and ideal approach to it. There's no real point to cause a scene as they've already been through enough stress. And if they do have to do something, it's not like they HAVE to just reveal it to the whole school. Just send it to the school board and let them deal with it honestly. Again, there's no real reason to cause a scene or ruin their disastrous lives even further. It's too bothersome to keep this bullcrap up. P.S I think I think it was hilarious when he told the guy he wasn't going to touch him. Because his friends were going to decide his fate while he goes off to hang with the Fam. So he was right, from a certain point of view.