Loved by Her Sister’s Former Fiancée

Description

Links are NOT allowed. Format your description nicely so people can easily read them. Please use proper spacing and paragraphs.

A poor baron daughter lived under her sister’s shadow, where none was for her.

Her hair is full or hairballs, she doesn’t have a single dress, and all she has are tattered clothes for work.

Her sister got the attention of a high rich noble but died on the way to her marriage.

Marie was sent as a substitute bride for her sister, because the baron couldn’t repaid the already sold dowry to the Earl. But… that’s impossible?

In the first place, the proposal was a misunderstanding?

A beautiful and happy story of love about a fallen baron’s daughter and an eloquent Earl.

Associated Names
One entry per line
Zuta Boro Reijou wa Ane no Moto Konyaku-sha ni Dekiai Sareru
Zutaboro Reijou wa Ane no Moto Konyakusha ni Dekiai Sareru
Zutabro Reijou wa Ane no Moto Konyakusha ni Dekiaisareru
ずたぼろ令嬢は姉の元婚約者に溺愛される
Related Series
N/A
Recommendations
N/A
Recommendation Lists
  1. Fantasy--Female Protag
  2. JP Villainess novels with manga adaption
  3. Korean Novels part 1
  4. To Be Read

Latest Release

Date Group Release
02/20/21 djurasico c17
02/20/21 djurasico c16
12/19/20 djurasico c15
11/12/20 djurasico c14
11/12/20 djurasico c13
11/12/20 djurasico c12
06/04/20 djurasico c11
05/31/20 djurasico c10
05/31/20 djurasico c9
04/19/20 djurasico c8
04/04/20 djurasico c7
04/04/20 djurasico c6
01/13/20 djurasico c5
01/13/20 djurasico c4
11/27/19 djurasico c3
Go to Page...
Go to Page...
Write a Review
2 Reviews sorted by


sjmcc13
sjmcc13
November 27, 2019
Status: c20
I have read up to ch 20 MTl, but the author comments at the end of ch 5 that the story begins after that (so ch 1-5 are introduction)

Basically the MC's sister dies on the way to her marriage, the parents who have already sold (at a loss apparently) the dowry/gifts her fiance had given to arrange the marriage, and can not afford to repurchase them, so they plan to send the MC to him to offer a one night comfort in hopes he will not ask for the... more>> items back (basically saying he is grieving, and you are not getting married anyway, so go sleep with him so we can keep the treasures, oh and if the family falls because of this it is your fault not theirs. I can not really understand how they expect that to work, 1 night with a lesser daughter should not be worth whatever he gave them to marry their prized daughter, an I would assume there are brothers he has access to if he really needed that kind of comfort...)

The MC then starts to think about how this started, 2 months before on her birthday...
CH 2 :
Spoiler

basically, the MC's parents invited a bunch of nobles and wealthy heirs to a party to celebrate their daughters birthday, then made the other daughter the center of attention, to the point of buying her a new dress, and the only thing the MC got to do special was use laundry detergent to wash her hair and is wearing a very plain (and I think old) dress, and made it look like the preferred (and older daughter) was the center of attention and the birthday girl to anyone who did not know their names, though it seems that the sister tried to object and was silenced.

[collapse]
CH 3 :
Spoiler

basically the MC leaves "her" birthday party, and no one notices or cares.

She mentioned in her narration that the family is pour, and trying to marry their daughter off to a wealthier noble for an influx of resources.

After leaving she runs into a late arriving guest who mistakes her for a servant, before realizing that she is a daughter of the family, they have a conversation and he says they should talk more sometime, but she shakes her head as it is apparently forbidden by her parents.

[collapse]
Ch 4 :
Spoiler

She ends the conversation and leaves, apparently the MC is forbidden to discuss allot of things including that she has to attend a school for non-aristocrats, as well as other things for fear it will hurt her sisters reputation and marriage chances, she directs the man to the hall and the star of the evening (no names mentioned), goes to her room (which is a shabby servants room) and cries.

About a month later her sister gets engaged to a man that they do not know, and do not remember ever meeting

[collapse]
Ch 5:
Spoiler

the MC visits her sister in her room during the, apparently hellish, bridal training. sisters room is about 3 times the size of hers, and filled with much higher end furniture and clothes then the MC's. the sister seems to be stressing out over the upcoming marriage, the fiance seems to have a reputation as a woman hater, and they have never met, so she has no idea what he is like. With the way this chapter seems to read it would not surprise me if the sister faked her death to escape a marriage she as afraid of, she even shows the MC her secret (from their parents) hobby, and confesses what her plans were if the family fell into ruin. Which feels like foreshadowing to me.

The sister is no where near as bad as her parents, but I an not certain she was a good sister from what little we see of her, and even seems to give the MC some words of encouragement.

Her reflection ends, and the MC is back in the carriage to her sister's fiance. with her father ordering her around, complaining she is not cute, tells her to not stay in the capital and try to find work once the fiance gives her the boot, and even ends with saying he wished she was dead.

[collapse]

So for a MC we have a girl who is suffering from massive neglect as well as years of being compared to an unfair standard she can not live up to, and has all the issues that come from that. So we are dealing with a story of a woman learning her true worth, after being raised so she can not see any in herself
Spoiler

it is not that she had none, but her parents neglect and abuse has lead her to not being able to see value in herself, she has been told she is ugly so much she doe not even look at herself in mirrors, and does not recognize herself after being forced to properly bathe and clean herself since her family has not let her even get properly clean as opposed to themselves which caused some appearance issues like the hair in the description, on top of her family using her as their servant (getting up earlier, doing most of all of the house work, and it seems her meals where whatever scraps they left on their plates), plus is seems she was doing the paperwork for actually running their expenses and territory

[collapse]

For the Male lead :
Spoiler

Very predictably he is the man she met after leaving the birthday party, because no names were mentioned and when her arrived at the party her father directed him to her sister as the star of the evening he mixed up their names and got disgusted with the family, I assume there are some broken rules of etiquette involved and the parents were supposed to make sure to introduce everyone who asked to the person whose party was named on the invitations as the reason for the party (the MC not her sister) As a result he thought his proposal was rescuing an abused woman from a horrible family. But he was also interested in her before they parted that night, as it seems her mind impressed him (his mother if a foreigner, and she was the first person he met able to guess his ethnicity, as well as being fluent in his mothers language) and it seems could see signs of beauty hidden under the dirt and grime. No taming the beast or brutal woman hater, she accidentally won his heart with words alone. Also, he outright asks her is she was abused very early.

[collapse]

The parents are tr*sh, and it is clear in the first chapter, there is a little brother and heir to the house but he did not appear in what I read, so no idea about him. <<less
31 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Kingdo
Kingdo rated it
November 21, 2021
Status: c17
It's a nice story so far.

MC is severely abused by her family, treated as servant, eating leftovers, bathing in a well, etc... She is used to replacing her dead sister for marriage, because her dad already used the dowry. Turn out that her future husband swap the name between her and her sister and wanted to marry her from the beginning. The misunderstanding is understandable. ML went to a baron birthday party, he meet MC in the garden with an old dull gray dress. After having a good time with... more>> her talking, he went to the main building and meet MC's sister, in a beautiful pink dress, where everyone offers gift and praise. He asks who was the birthday and the answer was Mary, the MC. So he assumed the girl in pink dress was Mary, and the girl in gray in the garden was Anastasia. So he asks in marriage Anastasia.

If I give a bad point, it will be that the ML is delusional and more or less s*upid. He fell in love to MC with a single talk once and decide to be her knight in white horse. He organizes a marriage talk with her family and assumed that since she did actually come to his home, she is willing to marry him. He didn't think that her family will force her at all. Furthermore, he almost didn't talk to her at all, since he makes her bath and dress up as soon as she came. Then, before talking again, he presents her to his mother to have her benediction. It's when she screams that she can't do it before fleeing to her bedroom that he start to realize she has feeling too. He isn't a bad guy, he is willing to wait for her to open up and not pressure her to marry him. But for now, he is struggling to explain why he swaps MC and MC's sister name in the first place. Not that MC is the issues about it, since she did make some quick-witted thinking there and there. But really, this guys is just too socially awkward.

MC has many issues because she was abused, she has no self-worth, shy, too humble, always think she needs to work as a servant, etc...

But the fact that she accepts quite easily the bath was for her to bathe, not for cleaning it as soon as someone tells her, not saying think like "she doesn't deserve it" is a good start for her healing. She did studies by herself in her condition too, that make me think she is quick-witted.

Hypotheses about the sister
Spoiler

Since they didn't find her corpse, and we all know that no corpse = no real death. I think she is alive and just escape from the marriage.

[collapse]
<<less
1 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Leave a Review (Guidelines)
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.