RegisterLogin
Theme
Search
Series Group
If Only Time Stopped at the Moment We First Met
Type
Web Novel (CN)
Genre
Tags[ ]
Loading...
Tags List | Request Tag
Rating(4.3 / 5.0, 155 votes)
5    63% (98 votes)
4    17% (26 votes)
3    13% (20 votes)
2    3% (5 votes)
1    4% (6 votes)
Language
Support Book (#ad)
Author(s)
One entry per line
Artist(s)
One entry per line
N/A
Year
Example: 2012
2016
Status in COO
Status in Country of Origin. One entry per line
12 Chapters (Completed)
Licensed
N/A
Completely Translated
Original Publisher
One entry per line
English Publisher
One entry per line
N/A
Release Frequency
Every 229 Day(s)
Activity Stats
[Graph]
Weekly Rank: #7399
Monthly Rank: #13517
All Time Rank: #5058
Reading List
[Graph]
On 2119 Reading Lists
Monthly Rank: #17606
All Time Rank: #4630

Description

Links are NOT allowed. Format your description nicely so people can easily read them. Please use proper spacing and paragraphs.

The story of a seemingly one sided love between a school trouble maker and the class president.

Associated Names
One entry per line
Rénshēng Ruò Zhǐ Rú Chū Jiàn
人生若只如初见
Related Series
N/A
Recommendations
Gaze at the Scenes of Debauchery (2)
Social Outcast (1)
Friends with Benefits (1)
The Decade of Deep Love (1)
Recommendation Lists
  1. BL Novels I Love
  2. 2025 danmei novels
  3. To Read in 2025
  4. Please bear with my mediocre review #1
  5. Danmei Short Tragedy

Latest Release

Date Group Release
10/30/17 Exiled Rebels Scanlations c12 (end)
10/29/17 Exiled Rebels Scanlations c11
10/28/17 Exiled Rebels Scanlations c10
10/27/17 Exiled Rebels Scanlations c9
10/26/17 Exiled Rebels Scanlations c8
10/25/17 Exiled Rebels Scanlations c7
10/24/17 Exiled Rebels Scanlations c6
10/23/17 Exiled Rebels Scanlations c5
10/21/17 Exiled Rebels Scanlations c4
10/20/17 Exiled Rebels Scanlations c3
10/19/17 Exiled Rebels Scanlations c2
10/19/17 Exiled Rebels Scanlations c1
Write a Review
39 Reviews sorted by


Shorng
Shorng rated it
December 16, 2019
Status: Completed
I hate the ‘tragedy’ tag, but this one is an exception. To me, both the main characters are coward who live in their fantasy world, creating their own understanding towards the other without asking straight out for an answer.

Is it worth reading? Of course! It’s a short story, but it describes the unrequited love out there to those who don’t have the courage to confess to their crush or apologize for their wrong doing that no one can live forever. When you don’t understand their feelings or actions, try to... more>> ask. Try not to runaway from reality because you’re living in reality, you can’t live in fantasy forever, it’s a place where it will crumble after the time comes.

The story said; please do cherish your beloveds. <<less
27 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Otwentyfirst
Otwentyfirst rated it
December 18, 2017
Status: Completed
There were parts where I had butterflies filled with expectations. Unfortunately the MC was too cool for his own good so my expectations were never met. This is mostly a narrative piece with very few lines of dialogue. Usually I don't like stories presented in this fashion but for this story it worked out. I expected the ending but because the execution was well done it still hit in the gut and made me feel for the MC. I wouldn't say it's a tearjerker despite the "tragedy" tag but it... more>> did leave a lingering feeling.

The piece had some good points for consideration like autism, r*pe, victim mentality, coping, and regret. Those points make it sound like a depressing story doesn't it? Haha. No it's OK. But there is defo r*pe though so if you are sensitive you may want to skip chapter 4.

If there was a parallel story with the love interest POV it would have a similar vibe as this other story about a man who every morning would calculate the odds of him killing his wife and successfully getting away with it. Forgot the title. <<less
16 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
AnuBis28
AnuBis28 rated it
September 29, 2020
Status: Completed
Spoiler

MC committed su*cide, right??? An autistic person and also a r*pe victim with unrequited homos*xual love - the depression must be unimaginable.. And yet can't help but think, "Why ??? Why did it have to be him ???" It's always the victims..


Till the end, I couldn't sympathize with the ML.. I even felt "serves him right".. A rapist, a coward, a liar.. Why making girlfriends when you can't even love them for real ??? He even asked the MC to forget the past.. He had it coming.. Now live in regret for the rest of your life..
I remember the saying once again - "Three things that never come back.. The spent arrow, the spoken word and the lost opportunity."
[collapse]
15 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
cherryblossomsinsummer
cherryblossomsinsummer rated it
April 29, 2020
Status: Completed
"For him, I lived through many years of life being out of my mind." Probably my favorite line in this entire book, to be able to love somebody to the point of hurting yourself and the other person, it is really out of one's mind.

A good short read full of angst when you wanna take a break from HE stories. Will ab*se and make you curse, make you wondering nonstop about how everything would've been different if only one of them chose to talk. But none of them did,... more>> losing the chance for eternity. <<less
9 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Accismus
Accismus rated it
May 16, 2022
Status: Completed
Someone said upstairs that pres fell in love after r*pe. I do not condone it or say it was right. It was a crime. It was wrong.

But I believe that he loved him from the beginning. He blushed and cared.

This book is flawed but it is oh so real. It's more of a diary from a broken soul than a imagination from someone's mind. It was an confession of his crimes and woeful song of his feelings. He loved and loved and loved. Yet he was a coward. And who... more>> isn't in face of love. And a love that we believe to never bear fruit. A love that is scorned and cursed for simply existing. What he did was wrong and for that he was punished for a lifetime.

Many might belive how can you love someone so deeply and yet not know of it. But in places where homosexuality is not well known, love gets hidden inside other emotions.

I have been on a tragedy binge read and none of them made me wish for a different ending. Made me wish for a happy closure. Made me wish for my heart to stop hurting.

It felt real. From first word to last every single emotion is like a poisoned arrow meant to cripple you and make your heart bleed.

In the middle I wished to stop reading because I had an inkling of how it would end and yet I kept on reading and hoping that contrary to my beliefs the book would have a sweet end and yet it is a tragedy that has wrecked my heart.

After this review I will off to reading it once more. I wonder how many more will ? <<less
8 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
k24_isavid
k24_isavid rated it
March 17, 2021
Status: Completed
If you are looking for a story with perfect characters, fluff, this is not for you.

I remembered when I read this, it was night back then and I was looking through many short stories to read. I eventually decided to read this webnovel. It was a long time ago and I remembered every moment, every scene throughout this short story. That's how impactful it is. The MC is flawed, flawed, flawed (important stuff needs to be mentioned thrice). They have misjudgements and their courage to confess their love have... more>> been drained due to their current circumstances.

A bully and a class rep are usually cute tropes. This story shows what could happen because of an impulse, teenage hormones, and immaturity.

highly recommended, read other reviews lol.

DO NOT r*pe ANOTHER HUMAN, IT IS 100% VIOLENCE AND SHOULD NOT BE ROMANTICIZED. <<less
8 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Mimosa
Mimosa rated it
November 21, 2017
Status: c12
Maybe it was the mood I was in while reading, but the voice in my head that read line by line till the end felt dull throughout the whole book, yet I don't felt the boredom that should be accompanying it. Maybe it was my mood, or maybe the early premonition that the characters won't achieve their happy ending.

The story was so-so; I've read better in wattpad or in some other sites, but the attachment to the characters that you'll only feel in good books will be felt here, albeit... more>> temporary, it was there, hanging by a thread.

The story could be branded as a "breathe of fresh air" amidst the translated yaoi novels here in NU, although the characters designs are bland, their reaction to the events they're involved in are somewhat realistic, unlike most novels here where some characters personality makes you want to pull your hair because of how unprobable (comparing to how a normal person acts) their responses to stimulis (/events) are.

Spoiler

Hey, if you took time to read reviews, then read the story itself won't you? Maybe just this one because it's only 12 chapters. So yeah, go click on that chapter 1 link.

[collapse]
<<less
8 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Analayne
Analayne rated it
March 10, 2018
Status: c12
I read this knowing how it would end but what suprised me was how much it still hurt. Once you sheath your swords and if you stick it out till the end you'll get what I mean.

This is from a person who runs from that tag with full speed.
5 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
EUGEO SYNTHESIS
EUGEO SYNTHESIS rated it
May 25, 2021
Status: --
And here I am, still waiting for the author to continue this story, or maybe someone that want to make a fanfic from this story...

Whether it's being reborn or transmigrating, I just hope they have a happy ending... Because it feels so unfair, seeing two people who love each other can't be united to death just because they don't know each other's feelings.
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
ike_00000
ike_00000 rated it
June 23, 2019
Status: Completed
Honestly, I really don't understand the class president, I don't like this way he fell in love with him. But seriously this made my heart hurt at the end.

The problem here is, on top of how I don't like how the pres fell in love, is that the story was set up to be tragic. Like from one perspective this MC was just moping the entire time lol. Idk, someone who is a fan of the following tags would probably enjoy the story:

Yaoi, tragedy, r*pe, r*pe-to-love, misunderstanding. Frankly,

... more>>
Spoiler

r*pe that ruined a bright young man's life (because somehow he feel in love).

[collapse]

To be honest I was hoping for better based on the title and the synopsis (DAMN I love that title). Even with the theme of this story, I think it could've been much more enjoyable if they explored the other MC's character more. It's not a long read so in that sense not much to lose?

I just think every aspect of this story was amped to be more melodramatic than it had to. Like from the beginning there was *NO* reason for either of them to fall in love imo. I still think MC is a huge scum, not only scummy but also a coward.

I do think there's some elements to appreciate in this story, particularly the loser portrayal of the MC. Too often we can competent characters, so someone like this who hardly has the courage to own up to their wrongdoings & take responsibility for their actions is kinda fresh? Other than the unique theme & premise, idk if there's all that much else to praise... <<less
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
amruta
amruta rated it
December 22, 2019
Status: Completed
Great translation.

The tragedy tag says it all. If only the MC and ML had spoken with each other. They could have had a happy life. Alas, keeping silent only hurt them in the end.
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
KongKwong
KongKwong rated it
February 21, 2019
Status: Completed
Okay, it's my fault for not checking the tags before reading. Gosh, I hate tragedies! I end up crying every time, I wish I wasn't too involved in characters...

The narrative was quite unusual but not dull or boring, it felt somehow similar to my experience with 'Flowers for Algernon' where we got to see the story thought the eyes of the main character. It might be a cliché but for me it's a new and quite enjoyable experience, which makes the story and characters even more alive. And hence makes... more>> me cry even harder...

Spoiler

I can't quite understand our ML. His life was a tough one without a doubt, but he hasn't tried his best. He's quite similar to the MC in this sense, they both just gave up on themselves. It doesn't sound right to me, aren't we all greedy people who can only care about satisfying our own desires? How come there are two of them who just let it all go and didn't try to chase after their own happiness. I wish they could go back in time and do it all right. Now I completely understand what the author meant by the title of this novel full of sorrow and grief.

[collapse]

I'm going to give it all 5 stars because it's beautiful even if I can't completely relate.

And now I need a short and fluffy story to sooth my broken heart! <<less
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
PotatoCakes
PotatoCakes rated it
January 15, 2019
Status: Completed
This novel will either be a hit or miss. I got anxiety while reading it, and felt like sh*t after completing it. Which is why I would highly recommend it.

The characters aren't meant to be sympathetic, but they're both relatable in a way. Societal pressure, pride, and immaturity oftentimes manifest themselves in real life in similar ways. This novel explores what happens when all of that is mixed together with a series of unfortunate events.

Novels rarely incite so many emotions in me. Maybe it's because I rarely read novels with... more>> "Bad Ending" tags, but this one stood out due to the frustration both the characters and readers feel throughout the story. I wouldn't recommend reading it, unless you're not prepared for a whole lot of angst. <<less
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Lara Night
Lara Night rated it
October 2, 2021
Status: Completed
read this for the second time. The novel is short but eventful. I finish it within one hour, but it teaches us a lot.

-Love, do not regret your hesitation.

-Your ending could be better.

-Speak out.

I know this is just something written by the author, but it could be someone's real story. Or it could be someone's new story. I have a lot of things I regretted too. I wish I can stop hesitate now.
2 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
nctzen
nctzen rated it
November 20, 2020
Status: Completed
It's the first time that I read a story that I hope for a bad ending. I felt complicated because a happy ending means that the MC will feel happy at the end but at the same time I keep on feeling that the ML do not deserves it after what he did. This is a short but heartful story that makes me tear up in the middle of the night. "If you love someone, you should said it as soon as possible bcs if you wait perhaps the god... more>> wouldn't give you the chance to do so" Sometimes an apology is not what everything you need. <<less
2 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
yxyx
yxyx rated it
September 20, 2020
Status: Completed
This is really a depressing novel. It's well written, and realistically portrayed. Like the other reviewer said, this novel is a hit or a miss with no in between- you'll like it or you'll hate it but we'll all agree this is painful.

... more>>
Spoiler

I'm happy that they didn't get together. I just don't think that their relationship will work out given on how they started and the series of actions MC made after what happened. Either way, getting together or not, the MC will always be filled with guilt for what he's done while the ML remains in a depressive state - that somehow also turns into some kind of guilt.

[collapse]
<<less
2 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Achiless
Achiless rated it
March 12, 2020
Status: Completed
The MC is that guy who you should hate, and if you met him irl you'd push him from a building, but the story just makes you sympathise with him so much. Cause the drama. The drama. So much drama. *Squeel*

It's heartbreaking because you see the MC make mistakes over and over, and you know that everything is his fault but he can't turn back time. He's reaping what he sows, and he knows that. A short 12 chapters to cry about.

I think our lack of understanding of ML's (class... more>> pres') actions adds to the tragedy. We don't understand, so the MC would've never understood him either, which is why there are misunderstandings/unsaid words.
Spoiler

The mystery and (prob) lack of control that the ML has over his feelings made me sad.

[collapse]

Also yes, r*pe. No, romantisation. <<less
2 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
AKookieForYou
AKookieForYou rated it
October 21, 2019
Status: Completed
"Love once begun, will never end."

This was quite a dark story, and it isn't suitable for everyone. I have conflicting feelings about everything, and I can't really say that I enjoyed the story per se, but there were a lot of things I really related to. Especially the depression some of the characters went through.
Spoiler

I'm also not the biggest fan of bad endings, and this one was particularly depressing.

[collapse]
And that last paragraph was quite powerful. Overall this was just a strange experience. I think I'm going to go read something lighter to lift me up now.
2 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
hunhanakame
hunhanakame rated it
October 5, 2023
Status: c12
[Could be spoiler-y, proceed with caution]

In just 12 chapters the author manages to invoke all sort of thoughts and emotions. It's short but it really pulls at all your heartstrings...

Through the pov of the MC, we know how he was a child grew up in negligence while being supported with money. That set up could lead lots of good natured kids astray. The MC didn't really know about familial love. The reference he got because of the money and "freedom" he had was the only reliable support in his young... more>> life. The adults that should've guided the MC (including the teachers) indulged him. He was led around by others' ideas thinking it was his own. He was ignorant. It was supposed to be okay as long as he was given a few more years to grow. But his supposed "cute past naivety" became a blackhole he could never escape from. He was a child, not knowing much about the world outside of his narrow scope, being pressed by the unfathomable feeling of first love. An unknown fascination led to the plucking of a budding flower, in the end that poor flower not knowing it met that fate because of reckless admiration on its beauty only able to slowly wither, never got a chance to bloom.

The ML, his story is untold. But the ending gives the reader a sharp blow. Trace back and we can actually see the plethora of emotions he must have felt during all those years. Why was he adamant on disciplining the MC even with threats hanging over his head? How was he able to remain mum while being beaten up? During the assault, what kind of turmoil did he feel? Was he silently shaking in fear knowing there were people who had blackmail materials of him? How conflicted was he to feel attraction and longing towards his assaulter? And on the days after their last meeting, was he anxious waiting for the MC to come to his door and said his "Sorry, I Love You"? Or was he calm, silently accepting that he wasn't lovable enough, hence why he was savagely devoured and thrown after, even his pitiful last cry through that letter didn't move the man? I wish to know his story. But just like the MC, by the end all we the readers can do is turning everything over and over in our minds wondering about all the questions, unaswered. Although, despite the angst, there are lots of lessons to be learned.

I've been craving to read something short but heartwrenching. This story encapsulates that extremely well. Thank you to the author for writing this and thank you for the translator for translating and sharing this! <<less
1 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Yanwushi
Yanwushi rated it
August 24, 2023
Status: Completed
This novel hurted me the most, until now the pain I can't forget f*ck the novel is so good at the same time it broke my heart
1 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
1 2
Leave a Review (Guidelines)
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.

Novel Updates

User Tools

Latest Series

| Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Contact Us