This one is unexpectedly a very good novel. I really recommend it to others. At first I thought this would be the usual smut with no substantial plot kind of novel where the MC falls for his father in law after spending one night with him, they have will have affair and bla bla, the usual trope. But I was so wrong and I first had a negative impression of father in law, but he really is sincere, and nice person and was not interested in MC.I like both MC... more>> and ML and love how ML cares and supports MC. As for the smut, I dont think there was any? At from where I read there was no such thing.. THe plot is also very interesting, although the first few chapters are very tragic but overall its a happy story. <<less

This is a novel with a lot of missed potential. The premise and opening was set up well with a lot of drama and tragedy paving the way for redemption.

... But then... I don't even know. I had to double check to make sure I was reading the right novel a few times because it got to be so ridiculous and inconsistent.

Like at first, it seems like this is a modern novel, but then it just jumps right into interstellar after the rebirth? The gong is a president of a... more>> large company and then all of the sudden he's an admiral and member of the secret forces. And for some reason everyone and their mother and grandparents and nieces and nephews have super powerful military backing.

Not to mention, the ages are wildly variable.

In the beginning it seems the gong is 39 and the shou is about 15 years younger than him, but after rebirth the gong goes back 10 years in time and the shou is 18? Excuse me but there is a big difference between a 13 year old and an 18 year old. Ah, but the genre suddenly changed to interstellar and humans can live til 300 now so it doesn't matter, right?

I really hated how the gong kept giving his ex-spouse a bunch of chances. Like oh, he might be cheating. Now there's evidence of his cheating. But wait he gets 3 chances to make up for his cheating. Stop it!! Yeah, he's cheating, what more do you want! Do you need to stand in the room while they're shagging to be sure of it?!

Don't even get me started on the shou's personalities. Pre-rebirth shou was a depressed and lonely guy, while post-rebirth shou is a sunny boy. If anything, post-rebirth shou should have PTSD...

In short, this is a big trainwreck and I don't really recommend it. <<less

Although there's a bunch of drama in the beginning, later it's all sweet~

It's a slow romance, they don't get that they fell for each until way later.

TBVH I got stuck and delayed reading at the first few chapters because I'm so freaking annoyed at the dogblood-abuse! Lmao. Skim or try to tolerate the cheating ex-husband and the money-grabber mother-in-law. That part won't be long anyway. It's a rebirth+revenge story so the fun part is how the scum relatives will get what's due for them.

At first I feel awkward bcos at the start of the story they were legal in-laws (it won't happen again). Coming from the previous tragedy, rebirth made me realize they might have met... more>> in the worst way but they are actually best suited for each other. "Previous life" is pretty long. At chap 39 we arrive to reincarnating back to past life.

For the people confused, yes, ML returned to the past 11 years ago. It's just that the interstellar elements were consciously left out so the plot could concentrate on the casts but it has always been there in a low-key way. <<less

Great story ! Interesting and original because the protagonist thought that his life was ok until a fateful event and tried to correct it by saving his future son/daughter-in law from meeting her doom aka his own son (also making amends).

But on the road of rebirth, he discovered how his life was fake and how he needed to change the one thing on the way of his own happiness and found another road.

I really loved this novel !

This is a really bittersweet story (bitter then sweet). Yes, it's heavy on dog blood, but it's such a good story that you won't even care about all the dog blood. I was expecting myself to get confused and having a numerous "WTF" moment with the story's plot, but it's unexpectedly good and I'm glad that I'm giving this story a shot.

I really like how ML always thinking about MC well-being after he realized his mistake. Also a plus point that it's an Mpreg and the Shou didn't make me... more>> annoyed lol. <<less

Although, I have not read the whole book. I read up to chapter 2. I wish I can understand Chinese so I can read their great novels but unfortunately we can’t be given too much blessings.

So far, the chapters show an implied tragic romance between the father-in-law and the son-in-law.

The culprit.... As many yaoi novels like it. The woman should be the villain.

Why I gave this novel a 5.0 vote? Because it piqued my interest and attention. Not because of the s*x but the anticipation of how this author will... more>> solve these complex problems behind the setting of his story.

I look forward to more chapters. <<less

This novel, whew.. In my case angst lol it was a full on angst for someone like me who gets emotional reading this story. In my opinion, this story is hard to describe in one word tbh. All I know is that for a story to get me crying, laughing, smiling, stay up, disgusted at characters in the story. It’s a good one. I thought it was just a smut novel with no plot or something but maaaaan am I wrong! I’ve never hated the father in law or the... more>> son in law which I stand right lol I can literally see how the father in law was sincere and trying to make everything better for his son in law after that incident. I was in a rollercoaster ride for this one. And the smut?? F*ckin wholesome between them two in the later later chapters. HE for this novel and I like the ending. Karma really be coming for the villains tbh. As usual lol <<less

The description caught me, I looked for the story and I can say that I looked for copper and found gold, I really liked the development of the characters.

MC and ML had the opportunity to be together despite the difficulties and their past, this story could have had more chapters and had you hooked, but I still liked it a lot.

Really thought I would hate this story but it was interesting more than I expected!

Just make sure to read the tags before reading.

Waiting for more chapters.

I like this novel.. It's a bittersweet novel.. When I read the first quarter chapter I felt very sad for MC, ML (not much) and children.. This novel has more potential to be very much.. And I really enjoyed reading this novel..

Thank you translator!!!

I read the MTL twice because I really love the MC. And it's rare to see ML with no cold-to-anyone-beside-you. ML is kind of dumb regarding love, but yeah I get it... Even one of my relative is like that (when people tell that you deserves better but the person doesn't think so). And each person has their own problem, especially the ML & MC.

I only regret that the friends didn't come much. The story really focus to the main characters trying to trust love.

For White Cat translator:
I am so happy that I cried when I see the continuation!!! Thank you!!!