Clear and Muddy Loss of Love

Description

Links are NOT allowed. Format your description nicely so people can easily read them. Please use proper spacing and paragraphs.

A natural moat called the Luo river split the great land into two. Jing of the north, and Wei of the south.

One was the Prince of the grass plains who had no worries nor sorrow. One was a lawful Princess who received exclusive favour of the Emperor.

A war turned the Prince of the grass plains into an orphan, she who had laid dormant for ten years had originally planned to become a sycophantic official, to manipulate the enemy kingdom into chaos, but was appointed as Fuma at the Chionglin banquet.

Wait and see, how this debt of grudge from a fallen kingdom and devastated home will be settled.

Associated Names
One entry per line
Jing Wei Qing Shang
JWQS
Kính vị tình thương
Revenge of the Prince
Truly Love Wrongly Given
Two Adamant Hearts
泾渭情殇
Related Series
N/A
Recommendations
My Wandering Spirit Lady (4)
Female General And Eldest Princess (4)
The Witch Nichang (3)
Eastward Flow (1)
Princess, Spare My Life (1)
The Noble Consort’s Pet Empress (1)
Recommendation Lists
  1. Baihe/Girl's Love that I've read and liked
  2. BL + GL
  3. danmei
  4. Yuri/Baihe Novels that really puts the meaning beh...
  5. quero ler

Latest Release

Date Group Release
05/14/20 melts extras (end)
05/12/20 melts c301-303
05/11/20 melts c291-300
05/11/20 melts c281-290
05/11/20 melts c279.5
05/11/20 melts c271-280
05/11/20 melts c271
05/11/20 melts c261-270
05/11/20 melts c251-260
05/11/20 melts c241-250
05/11/20 melts c231-240
05/11/20 melts c221-230
05/11/20 melts c211-220
05/11/20 melts c201-210
05/11/20 melts c191-200
Go to Page...
Go to Page...
Write a Review
66 Reviews sorted by


2013722
2013722 rated it
July 19, 2022
Status: c272
Altogether up to where I read, this novel was just two character studies on Qiyan and Jingnu, and of how they worked together. The development in each is very steady, and satisfying. They are full of contradictions; conflicting feelings, and bittersweetness. This novel is the type to be more of an experience to read. There aren't really any extraordinary meaningful elements to ponder over. The author ultimately uses a lot of other characters solely for the plot to keep going & impact on the main characters (directly and indirectly). Due to the lack of purpose other characters have, there's a limit to how developed the political schemes can become. At the surface, the politics + palace intrigue have a thoughtful, complicated structure, but there was nearly nothing beneath it. It was bleak with no great meaning. Considering that the whole story wants to be focused on the main couple, not diving deeply into others is alright but it gets off-putting from how especially ignored and used some characters get. It gives the vibe that only Jingnu and Qiyan are important in the world of the story, as if everything revolves around them, to kind of a disturbing extent. In one case, it was very gross
Spoiler

A character Li YuAn would be blamed for "bringing disaster" by the main characters? Li YuAn was trying to seek help / safety from Sixth prince who was planning to r*pe him. A quote to give you an idea where I am coming from, "they seem angry that i'd make myself vulnerable more than the fact they'd acted on my vulnerability." I get the whole hierarchy thing with how Li YuAn is much lower in status and "doesn't deserve" such, that further adds to the background, but it was unexpected when Jingnu also blamed him for it. Jingnu is shown to see all as equal, that she doesn't consider the hierarchy, this was shown numerous times. For example, when she disapproved how servants and soldiers' deaths of different status would get a different compensation, which happened AFTERWARDS too. Things just don't go together, the only excuse I can think of this was that the author wanted to show how unreasonable Jingnu can get, since she was jealous from Li YuAn "showing interest" towards Qiyan, which again proves my initial point of using characters.

[collapse]

I really hope by the end is when the other characters shine.
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
PeonyDancer
PeonyDancer rated it
May 27, 2022
Status: --
This author is absolutely amazing - Baihe is very niche compared to other forms of web novels, and within that, it's hard enough finding good authors. 'Please don't laugh' is one of them,

Finished this book in 5 days because I was sick and lying in bed, and for sure this book did nothing to help my recovery cuz I was reeling and sobbing almost every 5 seconds. Just when you think 'finally, the pain is over and they can be happy together' BAM! Something happens that causes you to... more>> lose all hope again and you sit there going 'why?' and yet YOU KNOW WHY and it makes sense why these horrible things are happening and there's nothing that can be done about it and that makes it all the worse.

This is gonna be a long rant that might have minor spoilers so read at your own risk:

I feel for Jingnu and Qiyan:

The Emperor was not the ruler of the Wei kingdom to Jingnu - he was a father that dearly loved her and sought nothing less than her absolute happiness. He gave her every honour that men could receive in the ancient times without a care because it made her happy. I myself am someone who absolutely adores my father, and he's the person who gave me the will to live throughout all the struggles of my life. If someone were to kill him, even if the mu*derer was the person I loved most, not even ripping their flesh from their bones would be enough to satiate me. So what Jingnu did to Qiyan when she returned...I kind of get.

At the same time, Jingnu needs to understand that as the Emperor, her father unblinkingly called for the genocide and ens*avement of an entire race, all for his own expansion of power and sense of superiority as a Southerner. She needs to understand that those 'millions' that were mu*dered, ens*aved, r*ped, and tortured, are not just figures in a record, but each number was an individual who once breathed and walked the earth. That merely 4 of this million, were once Qiyan's entire world.

I understand Qiyan completely - I love my family. If someone were to impose such injustice onto them; were I to find out that my father died defending his people and his head was mounted on a stake and carried around to dispirit them, my pregnant mother had her twins forcefully cut from her whilst she was still alive, that my sister was r*ped and ens*aved, and my brother was forced to undertake the burden of the survivors on his own... gosh. I can't imagine it. I can understand why she'd want to pursue her revenge, even after falling in love with the daughter of her enemy. I can understand why the guilt on both sides would weigh her down.

The last few chapters of this book almost gave me no hope for a happy ending, and even at the end, the ending is slightly bitter-sweet. It's the happiest ending one can possibly get from a romance that's both clear and muddy like that of Qiyan Agula and Nangong Jingnu...

This was a brilliant book, and it's gonna be a certain re-read in the future. Highly recommend it, but a massive warning for s*xual violence, su*cide, war, graphic death descriptions, and a whole heap of heartbreak and revenge. <<less
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
fallinglikedominos
fallinglikedominos rated it
September 20, 2021
Status: c303
Before reading this, prepare your heart for a long and tumultous feelings that you will get.

It's beautifully translated. Full of angst! Like to the point where I needed to take some breaks and yelled to the pillow. I love the characters and their development. The premises and setting were nicely thought of. However, sometimes I feel like the MC is too op and I kinda rooted for the masked person. Too bad everything mostly went smooth for the MC, I feel sorry for the trauma she has to endure.

All in... more>> all, it's a beautiful story about revenge. <<less
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Elyurias
Elyurias rated it
January 12, 2023
Status: Completed
I don't know how to properly express my sentiments for this story. I read the whole novel in twelve days cuz I was feeling kinda possessed by it. I went to sleep every night thinking what would happen next and more important how tf PDL would make a happy ending happen in the novel. By the end, I wasn't really sure that a HE would be possible, but it was! The characters, the plot, the world-building, the sceneries that she describes are utterly unique. The slow burn, OMG, is the... more>> most slow burn that I've ever read in my life. Their first kiss comes only after 96 chapters and their first time only after ten years of marriage. Now, the angst.... that sh*t hurts as hell. As I said, I read it all in twelve days, and thanks God I did, cuz I cried every single day I was reading this novel. Well, this review is not useful, maybe one day I will come back to fix it, but right now my mind is only thinking about Qijing. In summary, I highly recommend this story for every person who likes historical novels filled with intrigues and court politics. Oh, one last thing, pay attention to your reading, PDL likes to use informations from earliest chapters to explain certains things in the future. <<less
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Upper
Upper rated it
December 1, 2021
Status: Completed
This is a rather complicated novel for me to rate. On one hand, I think it's a fairly well-written and intricately plotted novel that knew where it was going the whole time. On the other, to misuse Marie Kondo's words, "this does not spark joy". It's got nothing to do with how it's very, very angsty since I'm very good with angst, and I love a good "doomed-from-the-start" tragic story.

Ultimately, I think it's just that my expectations as a reader and where I wanted the anguish and tragedy of the... more>> story to go didn't align with the story the author wanted to tell. The author clearly knew and planned what the story would be like, and I just didn't vibe with it, and that's fine, that's just my personal taste.

The only real complaint I have is probably
Spoiler

the romance between Nangong Shunu and Xiao-Die. I get that the author wants their romance to be between two women with a traumatizing past with men, but I felt rather uncomfortable over the fact that Nangong Shunu fell in love with Xiao-Die's innocence and infantile purity, engaged in a s*xual relationship with her while she was still mentally incapacitated, and yet it was never brought up either by the characters or the narrative.

See I'm pretty blasé with romance tropes in fiction. Explorations of unhealthy, imbalanced, or non-consensual relationships is fine and safe in fiction and I really like them when it's done well. It doesn't have to be put under irl moral scrutiny all the time. With that said, maybe I do have a bottom line, and it's when one half of the pair is mentally in a child-like state. Xiao-Die's condition is temporary and she does recover her adult mentality later on, but it bugs me that it was never a point of conflict for the characters or the story, and that the main conflict of this pairing was only that Nangong Shunu was the daughter of the enemy. I think I would've been fine with it had Xiao-Die been given time to develop outside of Nangong Shunu's protection after her recovery, but even the stabbing incident was a total accident, and was even more somewhat a calculated move on Nangong Shunu's side. I would say that the Shunu-Die romance somehow stunted character growth/potential for both of them.

[collapse]

All things considered, I don't want to give this story a low rating since most of my grievances with it stem from my own preferences rather than the author's writing, especially since there was a middle portion,
Spoiler

between Qi Yan finding her sister up until Nangong Jingnu's ascension,

[collapse]
that I really did feel invested in. The main romance was also really well done; believable development, compelling conflicts, in-character for all involved, and nicely spicy sweet moments. So a 4/5 stars it is. I would definitely recommend this to anyone that wants a long, slow burn enemies to lovers lesbian romance with a mammoth of a plot, and probably not to those who're not into court intrigue/politics or severe angst. <<less
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
klownda
klownda rated it
September 21, 2021
Status: Completed
There's no amount of preparing my heart for this novel that would save my soul from being dragged and thrown around the feels roller coaster. I found Clear and Muddy Loss of Love via Melt Strules' (also the translator) fanmade trailer, and that is what primarily made me read it. Aside from the fanmade trailer I had no idea what I was getting myself into. The premise was unique enough to instantly catch my attention, and within just 5 chapters I was already invested in the story of Qiyan Agula.

While... more>> this is possibly the longest novel I have ever read (whoppin 303 chapters!), it was also one of my easiest reads ever. It took me about a week of constant binge reading to finish it, and I didn't find myself losing interest at all. There were a few moments where the story fell off and dragged on, but despite that I found great enjoyment in finishing it. For me the main driving force was Qi Yan's characterization and development of her as a person, whether it was her revenge driven fabricated personality, or the person she was becoming while being influenced by Nangong Jingnu. As for the latter, I also enjoyed how Nangong Jingnu's ''clean slate'' character developed over the time. While I had a few complaints about her, all of them were wiped away when I saw the countless interactions between the two and how their personalities clashed and worked together.

As for the plot, it was really well thought out. All of the plot points were resolved and tied by the end, the planning was fantastic, and I found myself on the edge of my seat during certain crucial moments. There's just the right amount of angst, tension and resolving the issues and that's what makes this novel so great. The revenge plot itself was also VERY well fleshed out, and I was pleasantly surprised to see the character's goals also develop as the story progressed. I LOVED EVERYTHING about it, even the bittersweet ending. I felt as if it was a rather fitting one for them.

I don't regret losing sleep to read this masterpiece in the slightest. I swear I didn't feel so many emotions while reading something in such a long time, I was happy, melting over the fluffy moments, being pissed off or downright crying. A literal roller coaster ride. After I finished the novel I felt so empty because of how attached to the characters I was, and because of the enormous impact it left on me. If you don't mind slow-burn stories and angst, I can't recommend this enough. The writing is PHENOMENAL. <<less
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Skythian
Skythian rated it
October 16, 2020
Status: --
powerful

the whole journey throughout all those long years makes me feel like I was a part of those journeys and the separation from those main characters as a result leaves me with a heavy sentiment. The character development as a result is the strongest point of this novel and leaves other slow burn love stories in the dust. Therefore, the novel's length is its greatest strength. Bittersweet.

aside from that, the author's knowledge and logical thinking style give the novel great substance and has taught me a lot about Chinese values.... more>> Although some parts felt like they were unfit or dragged on in the wrong direction, overall the novel is phenomenal and one I will remember for a very long time. <<less
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
flowerseeker
flowerseeker
October 2, 2020
Status: Completed
What can I say except wow. This is certainly one of the best webnovels I have ever read. The translation is similarly impeccable. I started Clear and Muddy Loss of Love almost immediately after reading Female General and Eldest Princess, the author's previous work, so I had high expectations that were definitely met. Wondering how the author makes two fated enemies fall in love? No worries, the author gives beautiful amounts of description, foreshadowing, and plot. The romance is neither the main factor or a background element; it's tied intricately... more>> into each character's thoughts and actions. The conflict is extremely realistically well written, and it feels like the characters are coming off the page with every word. The characters do not act for the author's - or the romance's - sake, they act for their own sake to solve their own problems and further their own goals. All in all, this is a gripping novel that made me binge read into the night for several days straight, shedding innumerable tears along the way. I recommend it to the best of my ability! <<less
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
DeaNoctis
DeaNoctis rated it
October 1, 2020
Status: Completed
This is an amazing story. I don't really know what to say and I have had my first cry in many years, so let's write a review. Yay.

Story/Plot?
Lots of plot. And plotting. This entire thing starts off as a revenge story, and -
Spoiler

the revenge IS fulfilled, leaving Jingnu alive!

[collapse]
a long time for them to truly realize their feelings - and for Qi Yan's identity to be truly revealed, all while embroiled in plots and treachery. Yum.

Grammar?
While I did notice some errors, they are scattered and do not detract from the story. The translation quality is very, very high, and there are little notes to explain traditions and events. The sentences don't flow awkwardly, unlike mine, though there is definitely a distinct 'I'm reading a translation' feel. It's not a bad thing, one might even say it's delightfully charming.

Feeling/Character Development?
Yes. Just, yes.

Overall, worthy of reading?
Dumb question, but yes. I am an extremely impatient, flighty creature with an attention span lesser than that of a goldfish, and I spent an entire three days pouring through this titanic work. (That is a very, very long time for my interest to linger, ok? Especially without waning. Shh.)

Other than it ignoring the handicap of me being the reader, it is still amazing. Plot, grammar, feelings, gay, gay, gay (important things must be said thrice), intrigue, what's missing? The only bad thing I can think of is the fact that it ends?
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
HolyGauntlet
HolyGauntlet rated it
September 6, 2020
Status: c250
An excellent story. Intense emotional suspense and a writing style led me to really sympathize with the characters. It was good and painful because of that. Definitely a good choice to read it. But I have one thing to say:

Spoiler

f*ck LU AND DING. I've read a lot of Chinese novels and seen a lot of brutal things, but these two. It is so messed up and disgusting, I wish they were real people so I could kill the myself. I don't even know what to say.

[collapse]
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
flowers_fury
flowers_fury
October 19, 2023
Status: c64
This novel is great so far! I love the complexity of the characters and the plot! However, I do have one question which I hope someone can answer for me. The first 10 chapters were locked to me somehow so I was unable to get some information. Nothing has impeded me until now. If someone could answer it or tell me how to access the first ten chapters, it would be much appreciated! I'll lock the question in a spoiler just to be safe.

... more>>
Spoiler

Why was Qi Yan said to be the prince of the grasslands and have the wolf tattoo of a male descendant? I can understand hiding as a man for revenge since it will give her more influence but why was she raised as one? If I didn't misunderstand the author said that she even had a younger brother, so I'm not sure why she had to hide.

[collapse]
<<less
2 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Chaengsam
Chaengsam rated it
April 2, 2023
Status: --
This was not a slow burn, a tragic burn. This hurt my eyes, heart everything. I very rarely hate mc's character. But this MC, What's I felt about her was that she is selfish, cruel and absolutely disgusting. The way qiyan treated jungnu, when all she did was give her sincerity and love. The MC just plotted schemes, manipulated her, the heck where is love?? I can't read this anymore I read more than 120 chapters. And I don't feel like reading about this selfish character anymore. Bye. But its... more>> just my opinion other people might love heart wrenching stories but I don't like these many schemes even between the cp. I now understood the meaning of the title. The whole story gets dragging and super dense with unnecessary details that bored the hell out of me. The author could have skipped those. And Jungnu oh my god I felt so much heartache for her. I understand MC wanting revenge. But I wish she had some ethics still stick to her. Like why are u doing this if you are the same as that rang emperor? You are almost as cruel as him at least to the chapters I read. I know in the ending they probably will have a happy ending. But I don't think qiyan even deserves jungnu's forgiveness. <<less
2 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
badatnamingthings
badatnamingthings rated it
February 15, 2023
Status: c307
Reading this novel felt like having my still-beating heart ripped out of my chest and torn into tiny pieces, 10/10
2 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
DreamChaser
DreamChaser rated it
July 2, 2022
Status: --
So this is a hard review to write.

There were multiple points in JWQS where I felt like I couldn't put down the book and marathoned chapter after chapter to find out what happened next. I loved the main leads and their romance. Qi Yan especially is just a treat of a character, the manipulative, cold-blooded chessmaster trope but as a woman. A woman who f*cks with gender on top of that. She's an incredible lead and tracing her development through the story is wonderful.

Nangong Jingnu also goes through almost an... more>> absurd amount of character development that never feels forced, and their relationship develops from the most delicious slowburn into something equally deliciously unhinged where they're feral for each other.

The plot, however... some of the angst hits hard, but quite a lot of it is dedicated to political maneuvering that I ultimately just didn't find that interesting. And that's coming from someone who really loves fantasy politics! But unless you're genuinely interested in the way a taxation or economic or trade policy might affect the imaginary kingdom, you're probably going to roll your eyes a bit the fifteenth time the salt reserve policy is brought up.

There are also a ton of different plot threads introduced, and while some of them are brought back around cleverly, a lot of the time it seems like we're building up to a big emotional climax, only for the story to resolve an issue at breakneck speed. Always with a solid, believable explanation, but it almost made me wonder why the author bothered to include all this if it isn't going to have a tangible emotional impact on us or majorly affect the lives of the characters.

This also meant that a ton of side characters are introduced and then barely used in the plot, which gives you lots of names to keep track of without much pay-off. I also desperately wanted to be rewarded for getting attached to them and see more interactions between these side characters and the leads, but at times it was almost like they were immediately forgotten about once off-page. This is all exemplified by the ending, which is a beautiful emotional ending for the leads but drops about a thousand other plot and character threads seemingly without care.

Spoiler

For example, we get a cool side romance with Xiao-Die and Nangong Shunu, but we never find out how their story ends or check in on them during the finale. We know that NGSN's mother disapproves of their relationship, but it's not really resolved in any way, just brought up. And surely XD deserves to know that her sister is alive at the end?!

[collapse]

The story in general seems chronically disinterested in anyone not named Qi Yan or Nangong Jingnu, which made me really crave more attention paid to their other relationships.
Spoiler

Qian Tong, for instance―we get this great setup with a servant who's incredibly loyal to Qi Yan and a cute scene of him fussing over her health, but there are so many opportunities for him to be around in a scene, talk to her, actually bond with her that just aren't taken until he needs to roll back around for more plot. Qi Yan adopts a new horse to replace the one she lost at the very beginning of the story, bonds with her, and then gives her away to Qian Tong to keep her safe, and likewise the horse is just never seen again. Bayin chooses to break things off with Qi Yan but feels conflicted about it, Jinwushu has inherited his grudge against the Wei kingdom but still wants to see his "father"... neither ever get mentioned again, and we only hear about the kingdoms being united sometime in the distant future, which makes all this division between the two virtually irrelevant.

[collapse]

Spoiler

And what happened to Jiya and her son? What happened to the main f*cking antagonist whose influence Qi Yan had been fighting against the entire story? The former princess just peaces out to the north of the Luo and never bothers anyone again? Are you kidding me?

[collapse]

It's such a shame, because there are point where the story really shines, and the leads are so compelling. The writing is, overall, carefully crafted and pays attention to detail. (Perhaps too much attention at times.) But by the end of the novel I was really craving something more character-focused, that gave me a little more downtime to just enjoy the characters being in each other's company. One that takes its time developing meaningful relationships with people who aren't each other, which at this length it could so easily have done by leaving a few of the less interesting bits of the plot to the side.

One last thing I'm going to mention, because it caught me off-guard and it generally isn't brought up or warned for in the fandom. I get that Qi Yan does plenty of awful things, and I largely love that for her, but
Spoiler

there is a very weird plotline about this beautiful man called Liu Yuan, who tries to get Qi Yan to shield him because he's caught the attention of the gross, lecherous sixth prince. Qi Yan and Nangong Jingnu respond by discussing how he's such a terrible inconvenience to them, and take the attitude that he's got a chip on his shoulder about being good-looking even though he says it's caused him to be nearly assaulted and bullied a ton, which we even see some of! They even treat it like he's doing something wrong because he doesn't want to be r*ped and is desperate to avoid it. And then Qi Yan straight up delivers him to the man who wants to r*pe him, while we get a fairly graphic description of how he's delivered naked and unconscious in a sack, and the guards who deliver him to the prince mock and grope him while he's passed out. This is never resolved, and we don't even get to see him conscious again after he's r*ped. We never hear about what happened to him after that, at all, and both the narrative and Qi Yan seem to instantly forget about him. It might have worked if it felt like it was intended to show how low Qi Yan is willing to go for her goals, but instead it feels like the story thought this was completely fine.

[collapse]

In summary, I feel like I was given my ideal lesbian romance, buried under layers of plot that could have been skipped or better focused, and side characters that should have been allowed to actually develop meaningful relationships with the leads and each other on the page. Reading this alongside Langya Bang also really didn't do Jing Wei Qing Shan any favours, because that one's a master class in balancing character and relationship development between all of its large, memorable cast and intriguing political drama, and even has another awesome, chronically ill tactician as the lead. Still, tentatively recommended for the sake of Qi Yan and the main romance. I've just been left wanting a little bit more. <<less
2 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
PianoGirl
PianoGirl rated it
January 19, 2022
Status: Completed
Clear and muddy loss of love was an exellent story about Qi Yan and how she falls in love with the daughter of her ennemy. The story is really well written and the caracters are all interesting.

However, "Spoiler"

The author just wants to see us suffer (which can sometimes be really good) BUT, the author with the plot just keeps writting senario after senario where everyone suffers and I know it's because of the main storyline, but I just don't like it (I'm talking about sunu's death that really shocked me... more>> just after the reunion between Qi yan and Jingnu and I wanted to stop reading). She didn't really have to die in my opinion.

I was a bit disapointed near the end because apart from the reunion between Qi Yan and Jingnu, the author doens't really develop the relationship between Qi yan and her "supposed kids" as an example. I was so sad for Qi yan's son who never really got to meet his family (I felt he was abandonned by the author).

Also, I felt that there was to mutch detail and I felt that the author could have done so much easier with much less. For me that was the main weakness of this novel because to much detail can get annoyoing to read.

Finnaly, the author doesn't really explain why the 8th Prince killed Sunu (maybe because of how she saw him with the knife? But he wasn't really obligated to kill her in my opinion as she was going to talk him out of it) or where the 7th Prince fled to. Or who was the father of Jiya's kid (I think the 3rd Prince is the dad, but the author doesn't confirm).

In conclusion, I really enjoyed reading this novel, sometimes it drove me crazy, sometimes sad, sometimes happy. I really loved the relationship between Qi yan and Jingnu and I wish we had more chapters of them. It took me 10 days to read it all but it was a very good experience. <<less
2 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
friedbanana
friedbanana
September 12, 2021
Status: -
I'm personally, not satified with the story. I felt depressed... To me it's really unfair for MC, she suffered enough.

But anyways, even tho the story not satisty me it doesn't mean that this is a bad novel. It's good. It's really good. The world building, the characters development.. Is all good. The slow burn romance in it is also makes sense and logical.
2 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
akien
akien
August 19, 2021
Status: Completed
This author never failed to make me cry badly....

Although there's probably only 1 Female Emperor ever existed in China Dynasties, I feel grateful for author able to grasp the real twisted experience during Dynasty life.
2 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Nirusituro
Nirusituro rated it
August 8, 2021
Status: c272
I like the story, I think the story had a great start, just that, my heart couldn't read more until Chapter 270's. I'm a fan of strong or intelligent female protagonist, and this had it. Its just that, my heart aches reading this. I tried reading it again from the start maybe it could arouse my want to read it to the end and also because I forgot how they end up together, but knowing some scenes in the future chapter made this extra painful to read. It made FGEP... more>> felt light. How the characters are written is amazing, the ups and downs in their relationship is absolutely fine. I'm not good at writting a review so bear with me.

I totally recommend it, as for people who managed read to the end and the translators, editors and all the people who worked on this, o7. <<less
2 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
oopsaloo
oopsaloo rated it
August 5, 2021
Status: Completed
Overall this novel is really angsty, filled with political intrigue and romance. However it’s worth it. My biggest complaint is with the ending. It seems quite rushed, and while I like the concept there are still some plot holes that never get resolved...

For example:

... more>>
Spoiler

The main villain - princess of the previous dynasty - is never mentioned again after she partnered with Jiya to start the war with northern Luo. However she tried to kill the MC and plotted so much against them over and over, yet we have no idea what happens to her. Does she continue to scheme? Did she get defeated? She just stopped being mentioned out of nowhere. Seems like a major flaw from the author, I highly doubt she just gave up and left because it would be highly inconsistent with her character settings throughout the whole novel.

also her 8th brother, Nangong Bao - he was never mentioned in terms of the ending, whether he ever got caught or not. There is an author note alluding to the fact that these are Nangong Fu’s problems, however we don’t really get any closure on this.

At least we get a tiny glimpse into Bayin and Jingwushu’s lives and those of the Chengli tribe.

[collapse]

Also, This whole novel gives Romeo and Juliet vibes, from star crossed lovers to
Spoiler

the faked death towards the end with the pill

[collapse]
<<less
2 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Yuikiss
Yuikiss rated it
February 23, 2021
Status: Completed
I was immersed reading this novel for these past 7days but somehow disappointed on how the author managed to end it.

There is so many potholes! It's like some main plot that was established from the start of the story became useless at the end. (I'm talking about the princess from previous dynasty and the possibility of rebellion from Lu).

It's a good read, sweet and slow. The Empress managed to know the real identity and true s*x of ML after reading 70% of the story and there was this separation of... more>> almost 9 years which somehow became irrelevant even if they got married at early age.

Anyways, I enjoy it but somehow frustrated how they end it rushly. <<less
2 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Leave a Review (Guidelines)
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.